Removal Waiver

Some years ago, I unsuccessfully litigated a case about a contractual waiver of the right to remove. (The unique facts of that case were that Collin County had no federal courthouse at the time, but the Eastern District’s Plano facility was under construction.) Collin County v. Siemens Business Services, 250 F. App’x 45 (5th Cir. 2007). That case prompted me and two colleagues to write a thorough survey of the law on this topic, see Coale, Visosky & Cochrane, “Contractual Waiver of the Right to Remove to Federal Court,” 29 Rev. Litig. 327 (2010), after which I thought I had “seen it all” as to contractual waivers of removal rights.

However, I was wrong, as Dynamic CRM Recruiting Solutions LLC v. UMA Education, Inc. examines yet another turn of phrase in such a clause–what it means for an action to be “brought before” a particular tribunal. The Fifth Circuit held that “by using terminology similar to that which courts have generally construed as forbidding removal, they were waiving their right to remove an action filed in Harris County district court to federal court.” No. 21-20351 (April 19, 2022). The article now needs a pocket part.

The post Removal Waiver appeared first on 600 Camp.

from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/48zrPWx
via Abogado Aly Website