Monday, August 8, 2022

(Podcast) Potential Changes to SCOTX Petition Practice | Justice Evan Young

Texas Supreme Court Justice Evan Young’s career has taken him many different places—the United States Supreme Court, Iraq, and now the Texas Supreme Court. Join Todd Smith and Jody Sanders as they host Justice Young for a discussion of his path in the law and his transition from practitioner to judge. Justice Young provides a unique, behind-the-scenes perspective on the Texas Supreme Court and its operations. He also discusses potential changes in how the



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/tRTpmrH
via Abogado Aly Website

Friday, August 5, 2022

A victory on tester standing – lawsuit by Rafael Segovia dismissed.

I’m not above patting myself on the back, and today Judge Sam Lindsay granted a Motion to Dismiss I filed for the defendant in Segovia v. Admiral Realty, Inc., Case No. 3:21-cv-2478 (N.D. Texas August 4, 2022). Judge Lindsay found, correctly, that Segovia had failed to plead the concrete and particularized injury and imminent threat of future harm required to maintain an action under Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act.  Segovia and his lawyers¹ have filed the same form complaint in at least 31 lawsuits in the Northern District of Texas, and every single one of those cases that is still open should be subject to dismissal based on the same reasoning used by Judge Lindsay.² This isn’t, by the way, Segovia’s first setback. In June he voluntarily dismissed a lawsuit against another of my clients because he had made a fatal error when amending his complaint to avoid my original motion to dismiss. In July his attorneys voluntarily dismissed an almost identical complaint against one of my clients (though filed by a different serial ADA filer) rather than face the possibility of losing on summary judgment.

The conventional wisdom in the kind of serial ADA case filed by Segovia is that a quick settlement is the cheapest way out, but with Judge Lindsay’s opinion clients willing to take some risk could well decide they are not interested in paying off plaintiffs like Segovia whose industrial approach to litigation seems to be more about making money than helping those with disabilities.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

¹ He was represented in this case by William Strickland. He is represented in others by Matthew Sapp and Michael Sturgill of the Sapp Sturgill firm.

² Other District Judges are not obligated to agree with their colleagues, so other judges in the Northern District might reach a different result, but it is reasonable to hope other judges will appreciate the value of consistency among different courts when confronted with identical claims.

 

 



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/8bG047W
via Abogado Aly Website

Thursday, August 4, 2022

West Virginia vs. EPA: A Recap and What it Means

In a decision that effected a major change to the federal government’s ability to regulate, the Supreme Court of the United States struck down the Environmental Protection Agency’s greenhouse gasses rules. In its interpretation of a section of the Clean Air Act, the Supreme Court applied a legal principle that could impact far more government regulation than just the EPA’s regulation of emissions.

In West Virginia vs. EPA, West Virginia challenged an Obama Administration-era set of rules aimed at government coal-powered plants. The rules addressed carbon dioxide emissions from existing coal- and natural-gas-fired power plants. The EPA had promulgated a set of rules based on the authority it believed it had from Section 111(d) of the Clean Air Act. What was notable about these rules is that they did not contain measures that would have required power plant owners to operate their plants in a cleaner manner. Instead, they attempted to shift the overall mix of pollutants in the nation’s air. These rules incontrovertibly went a step beyond prior environmental regulations. Under the EPA’s rules, the agency decided the proportion of coal-fired power as part of the nation’s overall output should drop from 38 percent to 27 percent to reduce emissions.

The EPA Was Attempting to Reduce Production from Coal-Powered Plants

For its authority to do so, the EPA cited to the section of the law that allowed it to regulate emissions of non-criteria, non-hazardous air pollutants from stationary sources through the identification of the “best system of emission reduction” that is “adequately demonstrated.” In this case, the EPA’s rules required either a reduction of production of coal-fired power or that the companies subsidize production of other forms of cleaner energy. The EPA’s rules had a clear purpose to make solar and wind power a more prominent part of national power production.

West Virginia argued that the EPA’s rules exceeded the statutory authority the agency had under the Clean Air Act. The state was following up on arguments the Trump Administration made when it suspended these rules in 2019. The essence of the argument is that rule changes these momentous could only be made in a law passed by Congress, as opposed to being contained in rules made by unelected federal agency staffers.

The Court Concluded the EPA Exceeded its Authority Under the Major Questions Doctrine

The Supreme Court considered whether the EPA’s rules were permitted by the statutory authority it was granted by Section 111(d). Ultimately, a six-judge majority concluded they were not. The Court reviewed Section 111 within the context of the EPA’s overall authority and found it was an ancillary statute meant to fill gaps not addressed by the EPA’s other authority. Specifically, the emissions by these coal-fired power plants were addressed by other authorities, so using the very broad authority conferred by Section 111 was unnecessary.

The linchpin of the Court’s decision was the “major questions” doctrine. There is a body of case law that has considered whether agencies have attempted to assert power beyond what Congress could have intended when they are asserting a highly consequential power. Here, the Supreme Court concluded the EPA was trying to take a “long-extant” part of a statute and use it to initiate a “transformative expansion in [its] regulatory authority.”

In “major questions” cases, the Court requires that Congress be the one to make these changes to the law, rather than an agency greatly expanding the law through regulation. The Court explained that it was highly unlikely that Congress would have given the EPA this breadth of discretion to fundamentally change an entire sector of the American economy. The Court concluded that Congress had considered and rejected similar changes, even after learning of the dangers of greenhouse gasses.

West Virginia vs. EPA Is About Far More than Climate Change

In setting aside the EPA’s regulations, the Court did not express an opinion about the merits of the EPA’s rules. It could be that Congress makes a decision that would impose the same caps and requirements. The main holding was that it needs to be Congress that does this as opposed to the EPA.

While West Virginia vs. EPA was touted in the media as a case about climate change, its real impact extends far beyond environmental issues. At its core, the case was about the government’s ability to regulate in general. Agencies issue and enforce rules based on laws and the authority given to them by Congress. The Court explicitly disclaimed that it was taking any stance on climate change. The real issue is what can be done by executive agencies and what must be done by Congress.

It must not go unstated that West Virginia vs. EPA is the most consequential Supreme Court decision in administrative law since Chevron vs. National Resources Defense Council. While Chevron expanded the federal government’s deference toward an agency that interprets a statute and takes action based on that interpretation, West Virginia vs. EPA held that some issues should be the subject of laws as opposed to a regulation based on laws. As much as “Chevron deference” served to expand the administrative state, West Virginia vs. EPA could remove many of the foundational underpinnings for it.

The question is where this leaves the ability of executive branch agencies to regulate going forward. West Virginia vs. EPA involved a transformative approach that sought to change an entire sector. Arguably, the EPA’s rules were one of the more ambitious programs done under executive rulemaking. However, it would be logical to expect that some would use the opening provided in West Virginia vs. EPA to challenge further government rules that may be less far-reaching than the ones proposed by the EPA. The key will be how the Court defines “major questions” in future cases that are sure to come before it.

The post West Virginia vs. EPA: A Recap and What it Means appeared first on MehaffyWeber.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/lBQsSnY
via Abogado Aly Website

Did the Fifth Circuit Get it Right When it Said that Manifestation of a Disability Does Not Excuse Bad Conduct?

Today’s case of the day is Harkey v. NextGen Healthcare, Inc., here, decided by the Fifth Circuit in a per curiam decision on July 15, 2022. The case is better known as the sleepwalker claiming disability discrimination case, and it has been over the legal blogosphere due to its sensational facts, which are described in detail below. As usual, the blog entry is divided into categories and they are: facts; court’s reasoning that summary judgment for the employer was justified; my thoughts on why this decision could have gone the other way; and thoughts/takeaways/questions. Of course, the reader is free to focus on any or all of the categories.

 

I

Facts (taken directly from the opinion)

NextGen hired Jennifer Harkey in March 2008 as an “Implementation Specialist.”[**] She worked without incident for over a decade. In September 2018, she was promoted to the position of “Sales Specialist,” effective November 1, 2018.

On the evening of October 10, 2018, Harkey was attending an out-of-town national sales conference for NextGen at a large hotel in St. Louis, Missouri. After a dinner and a few drinks with a female co-worker, Harkey headed up to her room. She then watched some television and fell asleep.

Around midnight, another employee of NextGen who was also attending the conference, Scott O’Donnell, had just returned to his room from the hotel bar when he heard a knock at the door. Rather than peering through the peephole, assuming it was one of the other men who he had just been at the hotel bar with, he opened the door. There stood Harkey, whom he did not recognize. Harkey says that she was wearing a “black cotton robe” that fell to her knees and that she was naked under the robe.

O’Donnell was startled and stepped backwards. Harkey entered the room without looking at O’Donnell. O’Donnell said something along the lines of “I think you’re in the wrong room. What are you doing here? You need to get out” and remembers repeating “You’re in the wrong room.” Harkey said nothing, walked over to a made bed and got in it, then pulled the sheets all the way up to her face. According to O’Donnell, “She just laid there, didn’t move and was nonresponsive to me asking her to leave and telling her she was in the wrong room.” Harkey did not touch O’Donnell during the incident. Moreover, O’Donnell states that she never propositioned him or sexually harassed him.

Still, O’Donnell was concerned. He was a married man on an out-of-town business trip, and a woman was in a bed in his hotel room. He called his supervisor, Sean Murtagh, to the room. Murtagh also did not recognize Harkey as a NextGen employee. Murtagh decided to contact Jill Burke, the director of Human Resources at NextGen, who was also attending the conference. When Burke arrived, she attempted to wake Harkey repeatedly. Burke pulled back the covers and Murtagh snapped a picture of her. Burke was able to waken Harkey, but Harkey was disoriented. Burke also described Harkey as “smell[ing] of alcohol” and “exposing skin.” Although he was further away, Murtagh testified that he did not smell alcohol and that her robe fully covered her, so that no “personal part[s]” were exposed.

Eventually, hotel security was called, and it was determined that Harkey’s room was next door to O’Donnell’s. According to Burke’s notes, which she discussed during her deposition, as security helped get Harkey back to her room, Harkey was “very apologetic” and embarrassed. According to Burke, Harkey stated that she must have been sleepwalking, which she had done from time to time when she was a child. Burke’s notes also recall that Harkey said that she “wasn’t assaulted or anything” in the hotel room, that she was fine, and that she was “so sorry.” O’Donnell went back into his room, gathered his stuff, and moved to a different hotel room.

O’Donnell was asked to write an e-mail about what happened. At that point, he was extremely uncomfortable “because of the accusatory-sounding questions that [Burke] had asked [him] earlier in the night about what happened.” Because of his discomfort at that line of questioning, he mentioned wanting to speak with a lawyer before writing an e-mail about the incident. He later testified about his concern with how his wife would react to learning about the situation and, more generally, about how it might be interpreted in the “Me Too” era.

The next morning, Harkey went downstairs for breakfast and business meetings. At some point in the morning, she was asked to go up to a conference room where she saw Burke sitting alone at a long conference table. Harkey said she had “a flashback” and remembered her face from the night before. Burke told Harkey to sit down and that she “was in very big trouble,” “needed to be concerned,” and that Burke wanted to discuss last night. Harkey told her about the evening, as she could recall it. Harkey told her she had sleepwalked throughout her childhood but that it rarely happens. She was also asked about what she was wearing. Harkey stated that she felt from the beginning of the conversation that Burke had made her mind up about what had happened. Burke told her to pack her bags and that she was suspended on paid leave. Multiple times in the conversation, Burke called Harkey a “liability.” Burke told Harkey to “call a doctor,” and Harkey said she would quickly do so.

Harkey called her doctor for a referral as she was waiting for her flight home and began the process for making an appointment with a diagnostician, Dr. Sudan. Harkey sent an e-mail to Burke on October 12, 2018 (the day after the incident), informing her of the medical updates and assuring her that she was taking the situation seriously. On October 16, Harkey sent an e-mail updating Burke that she had been able to get an appointment with Dr. Sudan for the following week. Later the same day that she sent that e-mail, on October 16, Harkey was terminated.

When Harkey was able to see her doctor, he diagnosed her condition as somnambulism, otherwise known as “sleep walking disorder.” On September 4, 2019, Harkey brought a lawsuit in state court alleging that she was fired on account of a disability. It was removed to federal court, with the operative complaint alleging violations of the ADA and the TCHRA.

II

Court’s Reasoning That Summary Judgment Is Justified for the Employer

 

  1. The controlling question is whether the plaintiff suffered an adverse employment action because of (emphasis in opinion) her disability.
  2. Even if plaintiff’s sleepwalking disorder was a disability under the ADA, she was properly terminated because of what happened when she sleepwalked.
  3. The Fifth Circuit has previously held that where a plaintiff’s outburst was arguably caused by his PTSD, the company was justified in terminating that individual because the outburst also violated company policy.
  4. The ADA does not insulate emotional or violent outbursts blamed on an impairment.
  5. A prior Fifth Circuit case also held that an employee verbally abusing his supervisor for denying his vacation request was also grounds for termination despite the employee suffering from bipolar disorder. That decision said that while the employee’s reaction could have been attributed to his bipolar disorder, the ADA is not a get out of jail free card to avoid accountability for the employee’s actions.
  6. That plaintiff’s severe, unprofessional, and inappropriate conduct was purportedly caused by her sleepwalking disorder is of no matter, as the ADA does not give employees license to act with impunity.
  7. When plaintiff sleepwalked into her male coworker’s room in the state that she was in, the employer had a reason to fire her, and the ADA is no barrier to that termination.

 

III

My Thoughts on Why This Decision Could Have Gone the Other Way

 

  1. It certainly appears that the director of HR rushed to judgment and that little independent investigation ever occurred. I join labor and management side lawyers on social media talking about how a rush to judgment by HR is never a good idea.
  2. There was no interactive process.
  3. Magic words are not required to begin the interactive process, as we discussed here for example, and most certainly what happened here is enough to put an employer on notice that a reasonable accommodation needed to be discussed.
  4. Plaintiff told HR the morning after the incident that she had a record of sleepwalking in childhood. Remember, a person with a record of a disability, 42 U.S.C. §12102, is protected under the ADA.
  5. Plaintiff made clear that she was seeking the assistance of medical professionals to figure all this out, but the employer terminated her before that could all be accomplished.
  6. Bostock v. Clayton County, which we discussed here, has changed causation. The question is whether the disability was a determining factor in the termination. Arguably in this case, it was. Again, magic words are not necessary and there was a complete absence of any interactive process.
  7. It is an oversimplification to say, especially after Bostock, that sleepwalking being the cause of the conduct is of no matter.

 

IV

Thoughts/Takeaways/Questions

 

  1. Was plaintiff a valuable employee? She worked there without incident for over a decade and had been promoted to the position of sales specialist.
  2. Did plaintiff ever have to work with Scott O’Donnell, the person whose room she walked into, in her job?
  3. Was plaintiff a direct threat to anyone during the incident or in the future? Could any future direct threat be eliminated with reasonable accommodations?
  4. I can’t see the United States Supreme Court deciding in favor of the plaintiff on this one.
  5. Could she do the essential functions of the job with or without reasonable accommodation? If not, might there have been another job in the company that she could have done with or without reasonable accommodations? Was traveling even an essential function of her job? Of any job in the company?
  6. The employer won this one. However, an employer would do well to look at §§III, IV of this blog entry prior to terminating an individual when something like this occurs.
  7. What company policy was violated?
  8. This isn’t the first time we talked about the line between how disability may manifest itself in the form of bad conduct. See this blog entry for example.
  9. The decision is a per curiam and is not published. I asked Prof. Leonard Sandler (a Clinical Law Professor at the University of Iowa whom I had the privilege of meeting in person just recently when I did a training for Disability Rights Iowa), for more information about per curiam opinions. He sent me this article. After reading that article, a strong argument can be made that our case of the day was not appropriate for a per curiam decision.


from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/VcSoXDB
via Abogado Aly Website

Everything You Need To Know About Fiduciary Duty

When one person is responsible for working for the benefit of another person as an agent, or in another position of trust, they will take on specific duties towards that individual. The highest form of duty one can owe another in that situation is a fiduciary duty. If a person violates that duty, they can be personally responsible for damages they cause.

Commonly, one assumes a fiduciary duty towards another when they act as a trustee. When one serves as a trustee, they take legal ownership of the trust assets and are responsible for managing those assets on behalf of the beneficiaries. It follows that a trustee must have principles that guide their work. The beneficiaries, while they need and expect the assets from the trust, are not in a role where they can make decisions themselves. Therefore, they count on the trustee to do their job properly.

Common Types of Fiduciary Relationships

Here are some examples of relationships that can create a fiduciary duty:

  • The personal representative of an estate and the heirs
  • Corporate directors to their shareholders
  • Attorneys to their clients
  • Investment advisors to their clients
  • Employees to their employers (in some cases)

Even though all these relationships are different, the core principles are the same. When you have a fiduciary duty to someone, you are being counted on to act in their interests and not yours. At its core, a fiduciary duty is about honesty and diligence because someone else is counting on you to do a critical job for them. They may even be paying you to act in this capacity.

The Core Aspects of a Fiduciary Duty

There are three basic tenets of fiduciary duty:

  • Duty of care – A fiduciary is expected to use reasonable care and prudence in carrying out their duties. This is similar to a negligence standard in a personal injury case. For example, if a trustee is investing, they should prudently consider all options, do their due diligence, and decide after considering relevant information.
  • Duty of loyalty – The fiduciary must act selflessly and in the interests of the other person. They must put others ahead of themselves. Fiduciaries can violate this duty when they engage in self-dealing or steer business to affiliated people or entities in which they have a financial interest.
  • Duty of good faith – This duty encompasses elements of the first two duties, requiring the fiduciary to do their job with prudence and care, and in an honest and honorable way.

Examples of Violations of Fiduciary Duties

Here are some examples of ways that fiduciaries can violate their duties to others:

  • An employee acting on behalf of their employer’s competitor while working for their employer
  • A trustee investing trust funds with a company in which they or someone close to them owns an interest
  • A personal representative commingling assets from the estate with their own, or taking estate assets for personal use
  • A trustee investing all the assets of the trust in dubious penny stocks or questionable cryptocurrencies

The fiduciary does not get away with the wrongful acts described above. When someone agrees to or assumes a fiduciary role, there are potential liabilities that go along with their responsibilities. Beneficiaries can be compensated for the losses they suffer as the result of a breach of fiduciary duty, and the money would come out of the pocket of the fiduciary who committed the violation.

Lawsuits for Breach of Fiduciary Duty

A plaintiff has the burden of proof in a breach of fiduciary duty lawsuit. They must first prove a fiduciary duty existed (it does not always). Then, the plaintiff must prove both an actual breach of fiduciary duty and the harm that came from it. Not every breach causes actual harm and damages.

If a plaintiff does win their breach of fiduciary duty case, they may receive the following damages:

  • Out-of-pocket damages that were caused by the breach
  • Lost profits
  • Mental anguish damages for the emotional harm caused by the breach
  • Possible punitive damages if the breach of fiduciary duty was particularly egregious

A plaintiff could also get injunctive relief from a court that could put an end to the challenged actions and/or order an accounting from the fiduciary.

Fiduciaries Must Do Everything They Can to Protect Themselves

It is critical that fiduciaries perform their duties, both to the best of their ability and with the utmost level of integrity. There are defenses to allegations of breach of fiduciary duty, such as business judgment, but you do not want to be in the position of having to answer for your actions in court. Litigation can be expensive and draining. If fiduciaries have any questions about the proper course of action, they should get legal help.

Here are some ways a fiduciary can protect themselves from possible liability in the future:

  • Get help from a professional if you find yourself uncertain about something
  • Keep detailed records of your transactions and the effort you made to honor your fiduciary duty
  • Listen to the principal and answer questions as they ask them, making sure to remain transparent

Breach of fiduciary lawsuits are almost always complicated and often bitter. In many cases, they involve allegations of wrongdoing by family members. Regardless of the type of case, the plaintiff in these lawsuits is usually outraged because they think they have been misled or let down by someone whom they trusted.

The post Everything You Need To Know About Fiduciary Duty appeared first on Feldman & Feldman.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/gvw2Zul
via Abogado Aly Website

Filing an IRS Whistleblower Claim – Insight from Director Hinman

The Tax Relief and Health Care Act of 2006 established the Whistleblower Office of the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”). According to the IRS, the Whistleblower Office is responsible for assessing and analyzing incoming tips to maintain the integrity of the U.S. federal income tax system.[1] Moreover, the Whistleblower Office pays monetary awards to eligible individuals whose information is used by the IRS.[2] That is, taxpayers can personally benefit by providing to the IRS credible evidence of tax underpayments or violations of the internal revenue laws.

Overview of the Whistleblower Office

John Hinman serves as the new director of the Whistleblower Office. In a recent article released by the IRS, he provided a general overview of the Whistleblower Office as follows:

Our nation’s tax system is built on the principle of voluntary compliance. When this principle is observed, taxpayers file tax returns and pay their taxes timely and accurately without the need for compliance activity by the IRS. Voluntary compliance is aided by the knowledge that non-compliance with tax laws will be addressed through examinations, collection activities, criminal investigations and other tax enforcement work. The IRS uses increasingly sophisticated data analytics and other methods to detect non-compliance with tax laws, but we can’t find it all by ourselves. We need help from whistleblowers – people with firsthand knowledge of non-compliance who are willing to share what they know with us so we can investigate it when warranted.

The IRS Whistleblower Office was established by the Tax Relief and Health Care Act of 2006. Each year, the IRS receives thousands of award claims from individuals who identify taxpayers who may not be abiding by our nation’s tax laws. My office ensures that award claims are reviewed by the appropriate IRS business unit, determines whether an award should be paid and the percentage of any award, and ensures that approved awards are paid.

Since the inception of the Whistleblower Office in 2007, the IRS has paid more than $1.05 billion in over 2,500 awards to whistleblowers. The information provided by these individuals led to the successful collection of over $6.39 billion from non-compliant taxpayers. The awards paid to whistleblowers generally range between 15 to 30 percent of the proceeds collected and attributable to their information.[3]

Section 7623

Section 7623 of the Internal Revenue Code, entitled Expenses of detection of underpayments and fraud, etc., outlines the framework by which the IRS offers awards for actionable whistleblower information. Awards are processed as either a Section 7623(a) award or a Section 7623(b) award. Those provisions provide, in part:

(a) In General

The Secretary, under regulations prescribed by the Secretary, is authorized to pay such sums as he deems necessary for—

(1) detecting underpayments of tax, or

(2) detecting and bringing to trial and punishment persons guilty of violating the internal revenue laws or conniving at the same,

in cases where such expenses are not otherwise provided for by law. Any amount payable under the preceding sentence shall be paid from the proceeds of amounts collected by reason of the information provided, and any amount so collected shall be available for such payments.

(b) Awards to Whistleblowers

(1) In General

If the Secretary proceeds with any administrative or judicial action described in subsection (a) based on information brought to the Secretary’s attention by an individual, such individual shall, subject to paragraph (2), receive as an award at least 15 percent but not more than 30 percent of the proceeds collected as a result of the action (including any related actions) or from any settlement in response to such action (determined without regard to whether such proceeds are available to the Secretary). The determination of the amount of such award by the Whistleblower Office shall depend upon the extent to which the individual substantially contributed to such action.[4]

Section 7623(b) incorporates various other rules and criteria with respect to whistleblower claims, such as requiring that the information: (1) relate to a tax noncompliance matter in which the tax, penalties, interest, additions to tax, and additional proceeds in dispute exceed $2,000,000; and (2) relate to a taxpayer, and for individual taxpayers only, one whose gross income exceeds $200,000 for at least one of the tax years in question.[5] To the extent a claim does not meet the criteria for Section 7623(b), the IRS may still provide a discretionary award under Section 7623(a).

Filing a Whistleblower Claim

Individual taxpayers may submit a whistleblower claim to the IRS if they are eligible. The following individuals are ineligible to file a claim:

  • An individual who is an employee of the Department of Treasury or was an employee of the Department of Treasury when the individual obtained the information on which the claim is based;
  • An individual who obtained the information through the individual’s official duties as an employee of the Federal Government, or who is acting within the scope of those official duties as an employee of the Federal Government;
  • An individual who is or was required by Federal law or regulation to disclose the information or who is or was precluded by Federal law or regulation from disclosing the information;
  • An individual who obtained or had access to the information based on a contract with the federal government; or
  • An individual who filed a claim for award based on information obtained from an ineligible whistleblower for the purpose of avoiding the rejection of the claim that would have resulted if the claim was filed by the ineligible whistleblower.[6]

If an individual is eligible, he/she may submit Form 211 along with supporting documentation to the IRS Whistleblower Office. In the words of Director Hinman, the claim should be specific, timely, and credible. Accordingly, any IRS whistleblower claim should provide: (a) sufficient, relevant information and supporting documentation; (b) timely information for the IRS to properly act; and (3) information based on firsthand knowledge and/or reliable, documented sources.

Conclusion

IRS whistleblower claims, in the IRS’s view, are opportunities for individuals to help the IRS in detecting noncompliance with our nation’s voluntary federal tax system. Individual taxpayers may personally benefit from such claims by upwards of 30 percent of what the IRS ultimately collects based on the actionable information. However, individuals should be aware that even successful claims may take years to process (up to 10 years) to allow the underlying taxpayer to exhaust appeal rights, claims for refund, etc. Finally, taxpayers should be aware that the IRS takes certain measures to protect the identity of whistleblowers and that whistleblowers are protected from employer retaliation.

 

Expert Tax Attorneys

Need help with filing a whistleblower claim? Contact us as soon as possible to discuss your rights and the ways we can assist in your representation. We handle all types of cases, including cases involving IRS whistleblower claims. Schedule a Consultation Today!

 

[1] Whistleblower Office At-a-Glance, IRS, available at: https://ift.tt/ZXvMqWm.

[2] Whistleblower Office, IRS, available at: https://ift.tt/ihJXwMf.

[3] John Hinman, Director of the IRS Whistleblower Office, discusses how whistleblower information contributes to identifying noncompliance and reducing the tax gap, IRS, available at: https://ift.tt/AfMuP95.

[4] I.R.C. § 7623(a), (b)(1).

[5] See I.R.C. § 7623(b)(5).

[6] Whistleblower Office, IRS, available at: https://ift.tt/ihJXwMf.

The post Filing an IRS Whistleblower Claim – Insight from Director Hinman appeared first on Freeman Law.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/yZUPzlG
via Abogado Aly Website

E Pluribus Unum – A Child’s Question Leads to a Silent Courtroom

E Pluribus Unum – A Child’s Question Leads to a Silent Courtroom

In 2018 I prosecuted a criminal contempt action in a state court civil proceeding. The contempt action was very difficult for my clients, my law firm, my family, the courts, and opposing counsel. For the first time in my career, I received legitimate threats of harm from an opposing party, and the animosity among some who were involved had reached a tipping point the likes of which I had never seen before.

Somehow, and with cooperation from opposing counsel and the courts, a resolution was reached. I insisted that all terms, including testimony from opposing party (after being informed of and waiving 5th Amendment Miranda Rights), be placed on the record in open court. So, a final hearing was scheduled.

Two of my children accompanied me on the train from Grapevine, Texas to Fort Worth for the final hearing in the proceeding. While on the train, and as I was wondering what I wanted to say at that final hearing, one of my kiddos asked, “Daddy, what does E Pluribus Unum mean?”  E Pluribus Enum happened to be the title of the then-latest Stranger Things episode that we had watched together. I answered her question in a brief minute and then in the next five minutes wrote the content below to serve as my “counsel’s comments” about the contempt proceeding and its ultimate resolution by agreement of many who were involved in the matter.

The Honorable Judge Melody Wilkinson presided. My children were in the gallery. After all testimony and evidence was presented, I was given the opportunity to comment or close. So, I presented what I had written on the train. I was very emotional as I knew my comments represented the end of a difficult legal proceeding that involved many parties and diverse interests, a concurrently-prosecuted federal lawsuit, unique issues of law, and even law enforcement–the matter had taken quite a toll on me personally, the court system, and many others.

A few seconds into the presentation, the courtroom fell silent, listening.

MAY IT PLEASE THE COURT

E Pluribus Unum

My kids asked me what that meant as we were on the train headed to this hearing. That was the title of the latest Stranger Things episode that we watched, but it stirred a discussion of relevance here.

E Pluribus Unum is the De facto motto of the United States, debatable to the other, “In God We Trust”.

E Pluribus Unum means Out of Many, One.

I’m a homer for philosophical  aspirations like E Pluribus Unum.

I believe —perhaps naively—our Constitution and our tri-partite system of government is the finest on the planet. It is not perfect; but, in my view it is desirable and one I enjoy protecting on a daily basis.

Situations or actions that spur lawsuits such as this and its sister federal lawsuit between these parties put “In God We Trust” and E Pluribus Unum to the test.

Laws crafted by the Legislative branch are tested. The executive branch is tested to enforce laws that are in the books. And, our Judiciary—its Courts, Dockets and Judges —are tested in applying the law to a set of challenging facts and circumstances.

On behalf of my law firm, I am pleased that this matter has come to an agreed upon resolution.

I submit, the means expended to get to this end were not without hardships or trial. My family and my law firm were placed on lockdown for a period. For the first time in my career, I was worried that my work spilled into my home in a manner that put my children and my wife at risk.

But, with legal drafting and use of the Due Process clause, my fears were expelled through Court orders and Judges’ direction, and ultimately, we were able to get these two lawsuits in a posture for potential out-of-court resolution.

With direction from the Judiciary, and with the cooperation of [opposing party] and his court-appointed criminal defense attorney, Mr. Greg Westfall, and with a commitment for positive and amicable resolution from [my clients], and with trust in God, the many in this matter became one, and the Rule of Law leveraged to arrive at a resolution.

E Pluribus Unum

Thank you.

***************

The image posted with this blog is a section of the hearing transcript that captured opposing counsel’s comments immediately following my presentation.

It was a fine moment; one of my most memorable courtroom experiences.

–Cory

The post E Pluribus Unum – A Child’s Question Leads to a Silent Courtroom appeared first on Freeman Law.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/nugTk50
via Abogado Aly Website