Tuesday, July 26, 2022

Should I Add a No-Contest Clause to My Will?

One section of the estate planning questionnaire I send my clients asks them to rate their level of concern about various issues. One issue about which most indicate a high concern is that someone will contest their Will.

What is a Will Contest?

A Will contest is just what it sounds like — a lawsuit that challenges the validity of a Will.

Who Can Contest a Will?

Generally, only those who have a personal financial interest that will be affected by the probate or defeat of the Will can contest.

On what Grounds Can Someone Successfully Contest a Will?

Wills can’t be set aside just because the challenger doesn’t like what it says. Rather, the person contesting the Will has the burden of proving that the Will is invalid. The following are common grounds on which a Will can be contested:

  • Improper Execution: the person making the Will (the testator) did not sign the Will in accordance with state laws.
  • Lack of testamentary capacity: the testator was not of sound mind when he or she signed the Will.
  • Undue influence: Someone was improperly influencing the testator.
  • Fraud: Someone tricked the testator into signing the Will or forged the testator’s signature.

When are Will Contests Likely?

Will contests are most likely when someone who would inherit under the intestacy statutes ends up getting disinherited or receiving a substantially smaller share than they would have received if there were no Will. Intestacy statutes are state laws that control who will inherit your property if you die without a Will.

For example, suppose you are a single person with three children. Intestacy statutes provide that when a single person dies without a Will, his property passes to his or her children equally.

The incentive for a Will contest would not exist if your Will passed the property to all three children equally. That’s because the beneficiaries would receive the same share under the intestacy statutes as they would have under your Will.

However, if you create a Will that disinherits one child from whom you’re estranged, he would have an incentive to challenge your Will. Why? Because a successful Will contest would mean he would get one-third of your estate under the intestacy statutes.

What is a No-Contest Clause?

A no-contest clause is a provision in a Will that disinherits a beneficiary who contests the Will.

Taking the example above, suppose rather than disinheriting his estranged child, he instead decided to give him 10 percent of the estate, and each of his other children 45 percent of the estate.

A no-contest clause would provide that if the estranged child challenged the Will, he would risk losing the 10 percent of the estate allocated to him. A no-contest clause would not have any power if the challenger has nothing to lose by challenging a Will.

Are No-Contest Clauses Enforceable?

No-contest clauses are enforceable in most states. However, many states construe them narrowly and do not enforce them if there is probable or just cause for challenging the Will, and the challenger brings the action in good faith.

Taking the same example above, suppose the estranged child challenges the Will because he has evidence that his estrangement was caused by lies his siblings told their father so they could receive a larger share of the estate. In such a situation, the Court may find that the no-contest clause is not enforceable against the estranged child.

Additionally, courts have found that certain lawsuits do not trigger a no-contest clause. For example, filing an action to compel executors to perform their duty or provide an accounting will likely not trigger a no-contest clause because such actions do not seek to override the testator’s dispositive provisions in the Will.

How to Minimize the Risk Your Will Someone Will Successfully Contest Your Will?

There is little risk anyone will contest your Will if you intend to distribute your property to your beneficiaries in a matter that tracks the intestacy statutes.

If, however, you intend to make an unequal distribution or disinherit someone who would inherit under the intestacy statutes, take the following steps to minimize the risk:

  • Engage a lawyer to prepare your Will. A lawyer will be able to evaluate your situation and advise on steps you can take to avoid hurt feelings that can result in litigation after your death.
  • Make sure to properly sign your Will in compliance with your state’s laws. This includes not only following the requisite formalities but also going through the process of establishing testamentary capacity and intent.
  • Share the reasons you are making an unequal distribution so that no one is surprised after your death. Your beneficiaries are more likely to be dissatisfied if you keep the details of your plan secret.

You can’t control whether someone will challenge your Will, but taking these steps will increase the likelihood a challenge will not be successful.

The post Should I Add a No-Contest Clause to My Will? appeared first on Rania Combs Law, PLLC.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/6zGOojk
via Abogado Aly Website

Friday, July 22, 2022

Tax Court in Brief | Gonzalez v. Commissioner | Proving Up Business Expenses

The Tax Court in Brief – July 18th – July 22nd, 2022

Freeman Law’s “The Tax Court in Brief” covers every substantive Tax Court opinion, providing a weekly brief of its decisions in clear, concise prose.

For a link to our podcast covering the Tax Court in Brief, download here or check out other episodes of The Freeman Law Project.

Tax Litigation:  The Week of July 18th, 2022, through July 22nd, 2022

Gonzalez v. Comm’r, T.C. Summary Opinion 2022-13 | July 18, 2022 | Panuthos, J. | Dkt. No. 1548-19S

Opinion

Short Summary:  In 2015, Petitioner lived in Palo Alto, working full time for an employer in that city.  She also worked with a patternmaker in Los Angeles to make patterns and samples, having become interested the previous year in starting a business there as a wholesaler designing children’s clothing. Every other weekend Petitioner would drive from Palo Alto to a workshop in southern California, a trip of around 400 miles one way. There, she would review the workshop’s progress, provide supplies, and give further direction to the patternmakers.

Petitioner reported wages from her employer on her Form 1040, U.S. Individual Income Tax Return for 2015. On her Schedule C (Form 1040), Profit or Loss from Business, Petitioner deducted advertising expenses, other business property expenses, utilities expenses, car and truck expenses, travel expenses, and other business expenses.

The Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) allowed Petitioner’s Schedule C deductions for “Rent or Lease—Other Business Property”, advertising, and utilities. Nevertheless, the IRS issued a notice of deficiency disallowing her deductions for car and truck expenses, travel expenses, and other business expenses.

To substantiate her travel expenses, Petitioner submitted logs estimating the miles she traveled and other expenses. She also had receipts for two vehicle services in 2015 and 2016.  To substantiate her other business expenses, Petitioner submitted an invoice from her patternmaker stating that payments were made by cashier check for 25 patterns to a workshop in Los Angeles.

Key Issues

  • Was Petitioner entitled to deduct the car and truck expenses, travel expenses, and other business expenses that she claimed on her 2015 return?

Primary Holdings

  • The Tax Court found that Petitioner was entitled to deduct the car and truck expenses and travel expenses that she claimed on her 2015 return. However, Petitioner was not entitled to deduct the other business expenses that she had claimed.
    • The Tax Court determined that Petitioner’s tax home was in Palo Alto and that she was engaged in a trade or business in Los Angeles relating to the production of children’s clothing. As such, and after taking into account Petitioner’s testimony and the IRS’s determination that Petitioner could deduct certain other expenses in connection with this business, the Tax Court found that her traveling expenses were ordinary and necessary for her business in wholesale clothing design.
    • Furthermore, the Tax Court found that Petitioner had properly substantiated her car and truck expenses and therefore was entitled to deduct such expenses. Petitioner had submitted a mileage log detailing the dates traveled, distances traveled, and the purpose of each trip and had testified credibly about the business nature of her trips. Petitioner’s vehicle service receipts also corroborated the miles driven.
    • The Tax Court likewise determined that Petitioner had properly substantiated here travel expenses and therefore was entitled to deduct such expenses. Petitioner had submitted a log estimating her claimed meals and incidental expenses using the standard per diem rate for Los Angeles and had established the time, place, and business purpose of her travel.
    • However, the Tax Court found that Petitioner was not entitled to deduct other business expenses that she claimed for the year. Based on the invoice that Petitioner had submitted, the Tax Court was unable to determine when the payments at issue were made or for what purpose.

Key Points of Law

  • The Commissioner’s determinations in a notice of deficiency generally are presumed correct, and the taxpayer bears the burden of proving that the determinations are in error. Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. 111, 115 (1933).
  • Deductions are a matter of legislative grace, and the taxpayer bears the burden of proving that she is entitled to any deduction claimed. See Tax Court Rule 142(a); Deputy v. du Pont, 308 U.S. 488, 493 (1940); New Colonial Ice Co. v. Helvering, 292 U.S. 435, 440 (1934).
  • If a taxpayer can show that she paid or incurred a deductible expense but is unable to substantiate the precise amount, the Tax Court generally may estimate the deductible amount, but only if the taxpayer presents sufficient evidence to establish a rational basis for making the estimate. See Cohan v. Commissioner, 39 F.2d 540, 543–44 (2d Cir. 1930).
  • Section 162 generally allows a deduction for “all the ordinary and necessary expenses paid or incurred during the taxable year in carrying on any trade or business.” Boyd v. Commissioner, 122 T.C. 305, 313 (2004).
  • The taxpayer bears the burden of proving that expenses were of a business nature rather than personal and that they were ordinary and necessary. Rule 142(a); Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. at 115.
  • Section 162(a)(2) allows taxpayers to deduct traveling expenses if they are: (1) ordinary and necessary, (2) incurred while away from home, and (3) incurred in the pursuit of a trade or business. See Commissioner v. Flowers, 326 U.S. 465, 470–72 (1946).
  • A taxpayer’s “home” is generally considered to be his or her regular or principal place of business. Mitchell v. Commissioner, 74 T.C. 578, 581 (1980).
  • When a taxpayer engages in business at multiple posts, his tax home is where he spends most of his time, engages in most of his business activity, and derives the greater proportion of his income. See Folkman v. United States, 615 F.2d 493, 496 (9th Cir. 1980) (citing Markey v. Commissioner, 490 F.2d 1249, 1255 (6th Cir. 1974), rev’gC. Memo. 1972-154).
  • Certain expenses, including vehicle and travel expenses, require strict substantiation, through adequate records or by sufficient evidence corroborating the taxpayer’s own statement, of the amount, time, place, and business purpose of these expenditures. R.C. § 274(d).
  • Substantiation by adequate records requires the taxpayer to maintain an account book, a diary, a log, a statement of expense, trip sheets, or a similar record prepared contemporaneously with the expenditure and documentary evidence (e.g., receipts or bills) of certain expenditures. Reg. § 1.274-5(c)(2)(iii); Temp. Treas. Reg. § 1.274-5T(c)(2).
  • Substantiation by other sufficient evidence requires the production of corroborative evidence in support of the taxpayer’s statement specifically detailing the required element. Temp. Treas. Reg. § 1.274-5T(c)(3).
  • A self-employed individual can deduct meal and incidental expenses computed at the federal standard per diem rate for the locality of travel for each calendar day of travel away from home. See Proc. 2011-47, § 1, 2011-42 I.R.B. at 520.
  • An amount is deemed substantiated for purposes of section 274(d) if the taxpayer can substantiate the time, place, and business purpose of travel. See Treas. Reg. § 1.274-5T(b)(2), (c); Rev. Proc. 2011-47, § 4, 2011-42 I.R.B. at 522–23.

Insights: This case demonstrates the importance of keeping sufficient records to substantiate business expenses.  It may be tedious at the time, but it can really pay off in the long run.

The post Tax Court in Brief | Gonzalez v. Commissioner | Proving Up Business Expenses appeared first on Freeman Law.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/FXmquwO
via Abogado Aly Website

Applying Texas Sales and Use Tax to New Construction and Real Property Repair and Remodeling Services

One of the more complicated areas involving Texas sales and use tax is the taxation of various new construction and real property repair and remodeling services.[1] Determining what’s taxed and what’s not requires delving through myriad definitions scattered across the Texas Tax Code and Comptroller’s rules. It can get confusing fast. Here’s a quick breakdown.

What’s a “Contractor”?

Let’s get this out of the way up front. When the Comptroller says “contractor,” it may not mean what you think it means. The term “contractor” as used for purposes of the Texas sales and use tax is a term of art.  The term is defined as:

Any person who builds new improvements to residential or nonresidential real property, completes any part of an uncompleted new structure that is an improvement to residential or nonresidential real property, makes improvements to real property as part of periodic and scheduled maintenance of nonresidential real property, or repairs, restores, maintains, or remodels residential real property, and who, in making the improvement, incorporates tangible personal property into the real property that is improved.[2]

Notice what the term doesn’t cover: nonresidential repair and remodeling. That’s because while new construction and residential repair or remodeling aren’t taxable services, nonresidential repair and remodeling is a taxable service and subject to Texas sales and use tax.[3]

This is important, because the Comptroller uses the designation “contractor” as a way to distinguish between taxable and nontaxable construction services. This can cause considerable confusion to those new to the Comptroller’s rules, since the Comptroller has one rule for contractors (i.e., persons who perform new construction and residential repair and remodeling) and one rule for nonresidential repair and remodeling (let’s call them “service providers”).[4]

New Construction vs. Repair or Remodeling

The first thing to ask in determining the taxability of construction services is whether what is being performed is 1) new construction or 2) repair or remodeling.

“New construction” is defined as:

All new improvements to real property, including initial finish-out work to the interior or exterior of the improvement. An example is a multiple story building that has had only its first floor finished and occupied. The initial finish-out of each additional floor before initial occupancy or use is new construction. New construction also includes the addition of new usable square footage to an existing building. Examples include the addition of a new wing onto an existing building. Reallocation of existing square footage inside a building is remodeling and does not constitute the addition of new square footage. For example, the removal or relocation of interior walls to expand the size of a room or the finish out of an office space that was previously used for storage is remodeling. Raising the ceiling of a room or the roof of a building is not new construction if new usable square footage is not created.[5]

On the other hand, “repair” is defined as “[t]o mend or bring back real property that was broken, damaged, or defective as near as possible to its original working order.”[6]  “Remodeling” means “[t]o rebuild, replace, alter, modify, or upgrade existing real property.”[7]

As can be seen through these definitions, the primary factors in determining whether a job is new construction are whether the structure has already been occupied and, if so, whether new usable square footage is created.  If the structure has not already been occupied and the work performed is an initial finish-out, then the work would probably be considered new construction.[8]  If the structure has been occupied but the work creates new usable square footage, the work again probably would be considered new construction.[9] If neither one of these factors applies, the work likely will be considered repair or remodeling.

Again, nonresidential repair and remodeling is a taxable service, while residential repair and remodeling is not a taxable service. So, the next thing to ask whether the real property is residential or nonresidential.

Residential vs. Nonresidential

“Residential property” means:

Property that is used as a family dwelling, a multifamily apartment or housing complex, nursing home, condominium, or retirement home. The term includes homeowners association-owned and apartment-owned swimming pools that are for the use of the homeowners or tenants, laundry rooms for tenants’ use, and other common areas for tenants’ use. The term does not include hotels or any other facilities that are subject to the hotel occupancy tax.[10]

Nonresidential real property is not defined, so apparently any property that is not residential real property is nonresidential real property.

Taxability of Nonresidential Repair or Remodeling

If a job is purely nonresidential repair or remodeling, then the tax treatment is clear. The total charge (less separately stated charges for unrelated services) is taxable unless an exemption applies.[11]  The service provider generally would be able to issue a resale certificate to vendors for materials that are incorporated into the realty as part of the service.[12]

Taxability of New Construction and Residential Repair or Remodeling

If a job is new construction or residential repair and remodeling, an additional question must be asked: Is the contract lump sum or separately stated?[13]

A contract is lump sum if “the agreed contract price is one lump-sum amount and in which the charges for incorporated materials are not separate from any charges for skill and labor, including fabrication, installation, and other labor that the contractor performs.”[14]

On the other hand, a contract is separately stated if “the agreed contract price is divided into a separately stated agreed contract price for incorporated materials and a separately stated amount for all skill and labor that includes fabrication, installation, and other labor that is performed by the contractor.”[15]

“Incorporated materials” are defined as:

Tangible personal property that becomes a part of any building or other structure, project, development, or other permanent improvement on or to such real property including tangible personal property that, after installation, becomes real property by virtue of being embedded in or permanently affixed to the land or structure constituting realty and which property after installation is necessary to the intended usefulness of the building or other structure.[16]

So, turning at last to the taxability of new construction and residential repair or remodeling, if the contact for such work is lump sum, then no part of the charge generally is taxable, but the contractor must pay tax on the materials purchased for the job.[17]  If the contract for such work is separately stated, then the contractor must collect tax on charges for incorporated materials (unless an exemption applies), but may be able to issue a resale certificate to vendors on its purchase of such materials.[18]

Conclusion

Still confused? Here’s a chart that sums up the taxability of new construction, residential repair and remodeling, nonresidential repair and remodeling under the Texas sales and use tax:

 

New Construction

Residential Repair or Remodeling

Nonresidential Repair and Remodeling
   Lump Sum Total charge to customer is nontaxable; contractor generally must pay tax on incorporated materials used on job. Total charge to customer is generally taxable; service provider may be able to issue resale certificate to vendors for incorporated materials used on job.
   Separately Stated Only charge to customer for incorporated materials generally is taxable; contractor maybe able to issue a resale certificate to vendors for incorporated materials used on job.

 

And, of course, if you have any questions regarding the Texas sales or use tax or Texas taxes in general, don’t hesitate to give us a call to schedule a free consultation.

*******

[1] Part of the complexity in this area is due to history, that nightmare from which we’re trying to awake.  Prior to 1988, contracting and repair services generally weren’t taxable. See Acts 1987, 70th Leg., 2nd C.S., ch. 5, art. 1, pt. 4, Sec. 12 (adding real property repair and remodeling as a taxable service effective January 1, 1988). However, separately stated charges for materials incorporated into realty as a result of such services even then were subject to tax.  See Acts 1981, 67th Leg., p. 1551, ch. 389, Sec. 1 (distinguishing between the taxability of separated and lump sum contracts for contractors). As we’ll see, this treatment continues for new construction and residential repair and remodeling. Nonresidential repair and remodeling (and maintenance, which we won’t discuss in this post) could just be considered an exception to this rule.

 

[2] 34 Tex. Admin. Code §§ 3.291(a)(3); see also 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(a)(2); accord Tex. Tax Code § 151.056(d) (defining “contractor” as a person who makes an improvement on real estate and who, as a necessary or incidental part of the service, incorporates tangible personal property into the property improved.”).

For these purposes, an “improvement to real property” is defined as work to:

  • erect, construct, alter, or repair any building or other structure, project, development, or other permanent improvement on, under the surface of, or to real property, whether fee or leasehold;
  • furnish and install property becoming a part of any building or other structure, project, development, or other permanent improvement on or to such real property, including tangible personal property, which after installation becomes real property by virtue of being embedded in or permanently affixed to the land or to a structure constituting realty and which property after installation is necessary to the intended usefulness of the building or other structure; or
  • alter the land surface of real property by such means as creating roads, earthen dams, and stock tanks. However, mining or timber operations do not, in and of themselves, constitute improvements to realty.

See 34 Tex. Admin. Code §§ 3.291(a)(6), 3.347(a).

Generally, the question of whether tangible personal property has been affixed to realty so as to become an improvement to realty is determined by reference to the test set forth by the Texas Supreme Court in Hutchins v. Masterson, 46 Tex. 551 (1887).  See, e.g., Comptroller’s Decision No. 112,152 (2018).  Under this test, one asks three questions:

  1. Has there been a real or constructive annexation of the article in question to the realty?
  2. Was there a fitness or adaptation of such article to the uses or purposes of the realty with which it was connected?
  3. Was it the intention of the party making the annexation that the chattel becomes a permanent accession to the freehold?

Id.

 

[3] See Tex. Tax Code §§ 151.0047(a), 151.0101(a)(13); 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(b)(2).

 

[4] See 34 Tex. Admin. Code §§ 3.291 (entitled “Contractors” and covering new construction and residential repair and remodeling), 3.357 (entitled “Nonresidential Real Property Repair, Remodeling, and Restoration; Real Property Maintenance. (Tax Code, §§151.0047, 151.0101, 151.056, 151.058, 151.311, 151.350, 151.429)” and covering periodic and scheduled nonresidential real property maintenance but referring back 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291 when tangible personal property is incorporated into realty as part of such maintenance).

 

[5] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291(a)(9); see also 34 Tex. Admin. Code 3.357(a)(8) (stating that “new construction” also includes “the addition of a new mezzanine level within an existing building”).

 

[6] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(a)(12).

 

[7] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(a)(11).  Repainting is also remodeling, as is the partial demolition of existing nonresidential real property. Id.  However, a complete demolition isn’t remodeling and is nontaxable. Id.

 

[8] See 34 Tex. Admin. Code §§ 3.291(a)(9), 3.357(a)(8).

 

[9] Id.

 

[10] 34 Tex. Admin Code § 3.291(a)(12); see also 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(a)(13) (adding that “residential property” doesn’t include “any commercial area open to nonresidents, retail outlets, [or] hospitals”).  “Prisons” also may not be residential property. See The Geo Group, Inc. v. Hegar, No. 03-15-00726-CV (Tex. App.—Austin Aug. 10, 2017, pet. denied) (holding that a prison was a not a residence for purposes of the exemption for the purchase of natural gas and electricity for residential use under Tex. Tax Code § 151.317).

Note that the term “residential property” also doesn’t include “facilities that are subject to hotel occupancy the tax.”  34 Tex. Admin. Code §§ 3.291(a)(12), 3.357(a)(13).  This creates some uncertainty as to whether houses used for short term rentals are residential property, since short term rentals generally subject to hotel occupancy tax.  See Tex. Tax Code §§ 156.001(b) (stating that the term “hotel” includes a short-term rental, and that a “short-term rental” is “the rental of all or part of a residential property to a person who is not a permanent resident . . . .”), 156.051(a) (imposing a tax on a person who pays for the use or possession of a room or space in a hotel).

 

[11] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(b)(2). A service is unrelated if it: 1) is not nonresidential repair or remodeling or any other taxable service, 2) is of a type that is commonly provided on a stand-alone basis, and 3) is distinct and identifiable. Id. § 3.357(a)(15).

 

[12] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(e)(1).

 

[13] While the distinction between lump-sum and separately stated contracts used when determining the taxability of nonresidential repair and remodeling (presumably before nonresidential repair and remodeling was made a taxable service), it generally is no longer relevant for that purpose. See 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(b)(2). However, the distinction is still relevant in certain contexts. For example, “labor to repair real or tangible personal property that is damaged within a disaster area by the condition or occurrence that caused the area to be declared a disaster area is exempt from tax if the charge for labor is separately stated to the customer. The materials that are used to perform the repairs are taxable.”  34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.357(d)(9).

 

[14] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291(a)(8).

 

[15] Tex. Tax Code § 151.056(b); 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291(a)(13).

 

[16] 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291(a)(7).

 

[17] See Tex. Tax Code § 151.056(a); 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291(b)(3)(A).

 

[18] See Tex. Tax Code § 151.056(b); 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.291(b)(4)(A), (B).

 

The post Applying Texas Sales and Use Tax to New Construction and Real Property Repair and Remodeling Services appeared first on Freeman Law.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/jNySPfH
via Abogado Aly Website

Writ(ten) Before Us: Writ of Error Coram Nobis

Writs. We’ve all heard of them. There’s the writ of certiorari, the writ of habeas corpus, and the writ of mandamus, just to name a few. But what exactly is a writ and what does it do? Simply put, a writ is “an order issued by a legal authority with administrative or judicial powers, typically a court.” Historically, in the common law, writs were used to convey real property, grant privileges or rights, and to convey information. They were also written executive directives from the king, instruments by which the king could intervene into matters that were not resolved by feudal courts. Later, writs evolved, adopting a more judicial nature, acting as summonses or the initial documents in legal matters or as an order commanding a person to do something or refrain from doing something.

Writs are generally referred to “extraordinary remedies,” which means that they only issue when there is no other available judicial relief. Moreover, the granting of writs lies within the discretion of the court, which means that their issuance could be rare and not necessarily granted as a matter of right. The most common of the writs seen today are writ of habeas corpus, writ of mandamus, writ of prohibition, writ of certiorari, and writ of quo warranto. In this post, we will look at another writ, the writ of error coram nobis.

The writ of error coram nobis is a common law writ “intended to correct a final judgment by the same court in which it was rendered by redressing a fundamental error” and calls the court’s attention to facts outside the record that would have changed the judgment. The name of the writ comes from the Latin meaning “before us.” It is generally used in criminal cases and is most closely related to the writ of habeas corpus but can provide relief when habeas corpus is not a sufficient remedy. Although cases may differ on the exact number of requirements a petitioner must fulfill to have the requested relief under a coram nobis granted, there is some consensus that the following, at a minimum, must be met: 1) the judgment must have been the result of a fundamental error; 2) collateral consequences exist as a result of the judgment; and 3) the request must be timely, i.e. petitioner could not have sought relief earlier. Because of the high threshold that a petitioner must cross and because the granting of the writs is discretionary, writs of error coram nobis are more often denied than granted. Korematsu v. United States, 584 F.Supp. 1406 (N.D. Cal. 1984), however, was one of those exceptions.

In 1944, Fred Korematsu, a United States citizen of Japanese ancestry, was convicted of violating a civilian exclusion order that prevented persons of Japanese ancestry from a described military area, even though his home was in that area. See Korematsu v. United States, 323 U.S. 214, 65 S. Ct. 193, 89 L.Ed. 194 (1944). More than 40 years after his conviction, Korematsu filed a petition for a writ of error coram nobis seeking to vacate his conviction on the grounds of governmental misconduct. The court granted the motion. The court found that the government had withheld relevant evidence and provided misleading information. Specifically, the government had omitted from its brief any reference to contrary or contradictory reports from other governmental agencies refuting the need for evacuation in the name of national security but instead relied solely upon the assertions made in the “Final Report, Japanese Evacuation from the West Coast” (1942). The court found that the government’s failure to provide a full and accurate account satisfied the requirement that “coram nobis should be used ‘only under certain circumstances compelling such action to achieve justice’ and to correct ‘errors of the most fundamental character.’”

If you would like to learn more about the Korematsu case and the efforts to overturn his conviction through the use of this extraordinary writ of error coram nobis, please watch the recording of “80 Years Later: The Legacy of Japanese American Incarceration and Korematsu v. The United States,” a CLE webinar hosted by the Harris County Robert W. Hainsworth Law Library. [This recording is accredited by the State Bar of Texas for 2.0 hours of MCLE and 1.0 hour of ethics through January 31, 2023.]



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/59bzqE6
via Abogado Aly Website

Texas Court Addresses MSA Indemnity Obligations

At issue in RKI Exploration and Production LLC v. AmeriFlow Energy Services LLC and Crescent Services, LLC. were two Master Service Agreements.  RKI was the operator of a well in Loving County; AmeriFlow and Crescent were contractors. A sand separator exploded at the well site injuring or killing three workers who worked for another subcontractor. The result was three suits in New Mexico and a mazelike series of indemnity demands, denials, settlements, and judgments, including settlement of one death case for $9.1 million.

To preserve your patience, and mine, let’s focus on the takeaways from this 72-page behemoth of an opinion based on a 10,000-page record.

Grammar lessons

The court defined a phrase common to Master Service Agreements: “arising in connection herewith”. Indemnitees AmeriFlow and Crescent argued that the phrase “encompasses all activities reasonably incident to or anticipated by the principal activity of the MSA, which was oil well operation”. No, it doesn’t. The court determined that the phrase requires a causal connection between the MSA and the claims for which the indemnitee sought indemnity. The scope of work envisioned in the MSA was defined by work orders, and the indemnity could go no further than the scope of work.

The court considered the plain meaning of “herewith”, referred to the dictionary definition of “arise”, and concluded that although “arise” has a broad meaning it still connotes some causal nexus. If there were no connection between the indemnitee’s contract obligations and the indemnity obligation, an indemnitor would be required to indemnify even if performance was not an alleged cause of a loss. There must be a but-for causal connection between the indemnity claim provided for in the contract provision and “something else”.  What the “something else” turns on is the meaning of “in connection herewith”.

The required connection created by the use of “arise” or “arising” was limited by the additional phrase that narrowed the scope of the connection created by the word “arise”. That limiting phrase was “in connection herewith”. Citing dictionaries, the court concluded that “herewith” means “accompanying this writing or document”.  The court interpreted “arising in connection herewith” to mean originating from the document or writing in which the obligation is contained. The term is a description of the relationship that a purported indemnity claim must bear to the underlying obligations between the parties.

Did RKI waive its right to challenge the settlement?

RKI the indemnitor refused to participate in settlement negotiations, ignored demands for indemnity, and refused to enter an appearance in the suit for the indemnitee. This raised the question about whether RKI waived its right to contest defense and indemnity claims because it wrongfully denied those claims. if denial was wrongful RKI would be bound by the settlement of the underlying suit and unable to insist on adjudication of the indemnitee’s rights to indemnity and damages.

The premise of AmeriFLow and Crescent’s argument was that when an indemnitor denies its obligation, the indemnitee has the right to make good-faith and reasonable settlement with the injured party without judicial ascertainment of liability. Here, whether RKI wrongfully denied indemnity was not established. An indemnitor may not be held liable for an indemnitee’s purely voluntary payment to an injured party. The indemnitees assumed the risk of being able to prove the facts which might have made them liable to the plaintiff and as well as the reasonableness of the amount they paid.

Your musical interlude.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/XFn6fA4
via Abogado Aly Website

Nunc Pro Tunc, Sunk.

Fans of appellate terminology will recall a recent blog post about the distinctions among the words “rendered,” “entered,” and “signed” in the context of judgments. The Fifth Court applied those distinctions in In the Interest of C.D.G., a challenge to a judgment entered nunc pro tunc. The Court said:

  • “A judgment is ‘rendered’ when the decision is officially announced either orally in open court or by memorandum filed with the clerk. On the other hand, a judgment is ‘entered’ after being signed by the trial court judge.”
  • Therefore: “The nunc pro tunc requirement is satisfied only if there is some evidence that the trial court had, at some point before the original order was entered, rendered judgment inconsistent with the language actually entered in the original order. If nothing in the record shows that there is a discrepancy between the judgment as rendered and the judgment as entered, we are compelled to hold that the error in the signed final judgment was a judicial error and thus a judgment nunc pro tunc cannot stand.”
  • And importantly: “The focus is … on the actions of the court, not the parties. Thus, the mere fact that the parties entered into an [agreement] or filed it with the court, without more, does not translate that act into the entry of a judgment thereon by the court. A judicial error is an error which occurs in the rendering as opposed to entering of a judgment.”

No. 05-21-00132-CV (July 15, 2022) (mem. op.) (citations omitted, emphasis in original).

The post Nunc Pro Tunc, Sunk. appeared first on 600 Commerce.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/m2MUhTf
via Abogado Aly Website

Texas Series LLCs & Recent Changes to The Texas Business Organizations Code

Texas Series LLCs & Recent Changes to The Texas Business Organizations Code

The 2021 Texas Legislature made significant changes to statutory provisions governing Series Limited Liability Companies. Largely, they make Texas law governing Series LLCs more consistent with Delaware’s statute, the leading state series LLC statute. These important changes bring additional flexibility to companies, investors, and entrepreneurs in planning business affairs and intracompany relationships through Texas Series LLCs.

By providing additional definitional clarity regarding the rights and existence of series within an LLC, the recent changes will further the original purpose Texas Series LLCs: to help businesspeople avoid administrative complexity and expenses caused by replication of separate LLCs for related companies, projects, or asset-pools. For instance, instead of forming a separate LLC for each property, a real estate investor group can organize a single company and assign each real estate asset to a separate series, each of which might have a separate distribution of membership interest percentages.

Series LLC Changes to the Code

Principally, the changes establish new categories of Texas “series.” These categories are specifically defined as “protected” and “registered” series and are distinguished from the general category of series defined under Section 101.601 of the Code. The changes are contained in Senate Bill 1523 (87(R)) and they became effective on June 1, 2022. However, it appears the Secretary of State’s office is not yet prepared to implement some of the changes. The full text of the Bill is available here: 87(R) SB 1523 – Enrolled version – Bill Text (texas.gov)). The core changes of the Bill are to Subchapter M of Chapter 101 of the Texas Business Organizations Code (the “Code”), which is the Texas Limited Liability Act, but there are also important changes to other chapters.

What is a Series LLC?

A Series Limited Liability Company is an LLC whose company agreement establishes one or more “series.” In turn, a series is a group, designated by a company agreement, of “members, managers, membership interests, or assets” (1) as having “separate rights, powers, or duties with respect to specified property or obligations of the limited liability company or profits and losses associated with specified property or obligations;” or (2) that has “a separate business purpose or investment objective.” Tex. Bus. Org. Code § 101.601(a).

What are the Benefits of Establishing a Series?

In addition to the general type of series defined in Section 101.601 (an “ordinary series”), the Code provides that a series can be a protected or registered series. The core benefit of these series is that their debts and liabilities can be enforced only against the assets of that series—not the company in general or against another series, unless the Company determines an alternative arrangement. Tex. Bus. Org. Code §§ 101.602(a)(1), 101.602(d). Similarly, Section 101.605 of the Code gives protected series and registered series certain aspects of legal personhood, including the capacity to sue and be sued, to contract, to hold title to all kinds of property, to grant liens and security interest in series property, among other powers. This dynamic essentially allows businesspeople the benefits of limited liability for distinct business units or projects without having to file more than one certificate of formation.

If an LLC fails to meet the requirements for treatment of a series as a protected or registered series, by implication, it would be deemed an ordinary series and the general assets of the Company or any other ordinary series would not be shielded from debts or liabilities associated with any such ordinary series. In contrast, the Code provides that none of the debts or liabilities of the company in general or of another series are enforceable against the assets of a protected series or registered series. Tex. Bus. Org. Code § 101.602(2).

An ordinary series, therefore, is distinguished from protected series and registered series in that:

  • its liabilities are not limited to any assets assigned to the series; and
  • it does not have the aspects of legal personhood granted to protected series and registered series.

Consequently, an ordinary series does not place a series’ debts and liabilities in a separate “silo” in contrast to a protected or registered series.

Despite the lack of special asset protection for ordinary series, the Code clarifies that ordinary series can still be a useful contractual mechanism for allocating rights within the LLC. Tex. Bus. Org. Code § 101.601(c). With respect to separate series of assets, separate classes of members and managers can be allocated different relative rights, powers, and duties, including different voting rights, which companies can assign on any basis. Tex. Bus. Org. Code § 101.607. In summary, the ability to establish Texas Series LLCs generally creates two types of potential benefits: (1) liability limitations and (2) contractual flexibility to order detailed private rules governing company affairs and assets.

What are the Requirements for a Series to Qualify as a Protected Series or a Registered Series?

For a series to qualify for the special protection of its assets as a protected or registered series, an LLC must meet three requirements:

  • Separate Accounting. It must maintain records for the series that account for the assets associated with the series separately from the other assets of the company or any other series;
  • Statement of Series Limited Liability in Company Agreement. Its company agreement must contain a statement that (i) the liabilities of a series can only be enforced against the assets of that series and that (ii) the liabilities of the company in general or another series cannot be enforced against the assets of a protected or registered series (subject to certain exceptions); and
  • Statement of Series Limited Liability in Certificate of Formation. The certificate of formation of the company must contain a statement similar to that to be included in the company agreement.

Tex. Bus. Org. Code § 101.602(b).

After meeting those threshold requirements, a protected series may become a registered series by the filing of a Certificate of Registered Series with the Secretary of State. Tex. Bus. Org. Code §§ 101.602(c), 101.623. To date, however, the Secretary of State has not finalized an official form for registration of a registered series. The Code requires that a certificate of registered series must contain:

  • The name of the limited liability company;
  • The name of the registered series; and
  • The phrase “registered series” or the abbreviation ‘RS’ or ‘R.S.’ of that phrase.”

Tex. Bus. Org. Code §§ 101.626, (6b), 5.0561.

Security Interests

As a final step to assist Series LLCs in limiting their liabilities to the specific assets of a series, the new changes to the Code provide that:

  • The term “registered organization” (defined in Section 9.102(a)) includes a series if the relevant state law requires the filing of a public organic record (i.e., a certificate of registered series or similar document); and
  • The definition of “person” (defined in Section 1.201(b)(27)) includes a protected or registered series.

These updates clarify (1) that protected or registered series are separately capable of rights and obligations under the Uniform Commercial Code, including those of “debtors,” and that (2) security interests may be perfected in the assets of registered series through the filing of UCC-1 financing statements specific to registered series.

The existence of Series LLCs and protected and registered series as separate UCC “persons” indicates that Texas Series LLC’s and their lenders should draft cautiously when contracting for security interests in the assets of a series. But aside from the discomfort provided the newness of the law in this area, it appears that the separateness of series’ liabilities and assets may lead to greater certainty in lien creation by helping parties avoid unintended consequences. For example, separating series assets in silos could prevent the overlapping of competing security interests in “unrelated” company assets that can result from overbroad financing statements.

Conclusion

By clarifying the relevant legal framework, these recent Code revisions may bolter the use of Texas Series LLC as a useful tool for people doing business in Texas. However, only time will reveal whether their use will remain narrow or be widely adopted.

The post Texas Series LLCs & Recent Changes to The Texas Business Organizations Code appeared first on Freeman Law.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/O9q38Hx
via Abogado Aly Website