Tuesday, July 19, 2022

Anne-Marie Rábago and Joe Lawson among 2022 Fastcase 50 winners

This year’s Fastcase 50 award winners include two from the Texas legal world. Attorney Anne-Marie Rábago and law library director Joe Lawson are among those honored as “the law’s smartest, most courageous innovators, techies, visionaries, [and] leaders.”

Rábago is the founder and principal of Modern Juris, a program designed to provide tools and training to help lawyers and legal professionals to build sustainable businesses. Prior to this, she was the first director of the State Bar of Texas-sponsored Texas Opportunity & Justice Incubator. The incubator program also fostered self-sustaining lawyers with an emphasis on closing the access to justice gap. Through her leadership, TOJI became one of the largest legal incubators in the country.

Lawson is the director of the Harris County Robert W. Hainsworth Law Library. Under his direction, the library has increasingly looked to technology to make legal information even more equitable. Lawson engineered the Synchronous Touchless Assistive Node, or STAN, a device composed of a TV screen, printer, and CPU stationed in the library lobby. Run by one library staff member, STAN is used to assist patrons through a virtual meeting.

For information on the 2022 Fastcase 50 award winners, go to fastcase.com.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/Ba3hN2C
via Abogado Aly Website

Monday, July 18, 2022

EEOC Latest on Covid-19 and DOT’s Airline Passengers with Disabilities Bill of Rights

Last week, both EEOC and the Department of Transportation came out with guidances related to people with disabilities. The EEOC added to their running guidance on Covid-19, while the DOT came out with a bill of rights for airline passengers with disabilities. The blog entry is divided into two categories: latest amendment to the long-running EEOC document on Covid-19; and the DOT Bill of Rights for airline passengers with disabilities. With respect to the DOT Bill of Rights, what I did for that is cut and paste the entire Bill of Rights and then add my thoughts where appropriate, which is a tactic I have done before in this blog with other guidances.

 

I

Latest Amendment to the Long-Running EEOC Document on Covid-19

 

With respect to the EEOC guidance, Robin Shea in her blog, here, does a fabulous job of breaking down the new additions to the EEOC document. I am just going to add a few of my own thoughts. Otherwise, you can’t go wrong by looking at Robin’s discussion of the latest additions to the EEOC document. The EEOC document can be found here. My thoughts are immediately below:

 

  1. CDC guidance has changed radically over time and so has American behavior. The CDC guidance combined with American behavior means that direct threat is really more of a macro issue in a way that it wasn’t before. Direct threat is still going to be an issue with respect to a particular individual that is at increased risk of consequences should they get Covid-19. Otherwise, the CDC guidance, which really can only focus on hospitalization because so few people are reporting Covid-19 due to utilizing home tests, becomes very difficult to apply as a matter of practice.
  2. The CDC guidance can all change in a matter of moments. The BA5 omicron variant is becoming quite prevalent, and so everyone has to be prepared for changes at any moment in time.
  3. The interactive process is more critical than ever. The do’s and don’ts of the interactive process we discussed here.
  4. While the EEOC talks about how accommodation process might be delayed because of the pandemic, you do need to remember, as we discussed here, that an unreasonable delay in granting an accommodation is actionable.
  5. I recently read that 60% of legal professionals no longer want to work in the office full-time. I also recently read that for all kinds of employees the number is close to 50% for those not wanting to work in the office full-time. So, expect a lot of telecommuting reasonable accommodation requests.
  6. Direct threat to others in light of American behavior and the latest CDC guidance is almost impossible now to divine. The current CDC guidance and the direct threat analysis get a bit easier with respect to direct threat to self.
  7. The EEOC document talks about fully vaccinated. What does that even mean? Two shots? Two shots and a booster? Two shots and two boosters? I recently read an Israeli study that found a second booster was very helpful for individuals over 50. It wouldn’t surprise me at some point if the CDC says everybody should get a second booster. Even so, “fully vaccinated,” is a really uncertain term, especially if it is meant to convey a certain level of Covid-19 protection.

 

 

II

DOT Bill of Rights (Here)

 

Airline Passengers with Disabilities Bill of Rights

This Bill of Rights describes the fundamental rights of air travelers with disabilities under the Air Carrier Access Act and its implementing regulation, 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 382.

Please click this link to download the latest version of the Bill of Rights.

The Bill of Rights consists of:

  1. The Right to Be Treated with Dignity and Respect.
  2. The Right to Receive Information About Services and Aircraft Capabilities and Limitations.
  3.  The Right to Receive Information in an Accessible Format.
  4. The Right to Accessible Airport Facilities.
  5. The Right to Assistance at Airports.
  6. The Right to Assistance on the Aircraft.
  7. The Right to Travel with an Assistive Device or Service Animal.
  8. The Right to Receive Seating Accommodations.
  9. The Right to Accessible Aircraft Features.
  10. The Right to Resolution of a Disability-Related Issue.

Click on any of the rights above to be linked to an explanation of that right in this document. The Bill of Rights does not expand or restrict the rights of air travelers with disabilities. Rather, it provides a convenient summary of existing law. Because the explanations in this document may not be as precise as the regulations themselves, the explanations link to the actual regulatory text for your reference.

Important Information About the Bill of Rights

Does the Bill of Rights reflect current information?

  • The Bill of Rights is a living document. DOT will update the Bill of Rights as regulations change.
  • DOT published this Bill of Rights in July 2022.

My thoughts: interesting question as to whether the Bill of Rights, which interprets DOT Air Carrier Access Act’s regulations, will be given deference per Kisor v. Wilkie, here.

Does the Bill of Rights apply to me?

  • The Bill of Rights applies to individuals with a disability which is defined in Part 382 as persons with a physical or mental impairment that permanently or temporarily impacts a major life activity such as walking, hearing, or breathing.

My thoughts: the Air Carrier Access Act doesn’t always work the same way as the ADA. For example, it is possible that a temporary disability under the ADA may not be protected. We have talked about temporary disabilities and the ADA numerous times before, such as here. It also makes sense that temporary disabilities would be protected under the Air Carrier Access Act because it is quite foreseeable that a person with a temporary disability could be flying and need assistance.

Does the Bill of Rights apply to my trip?

  • The Bill of Rights applies to all flights of U.S. airlines, and to flights to or from the United States by foreign airlines.

My thoughts: what is a U.S. airline? The Air Carrier Access Act actually applies to all carriers, see here, which is a far broader term than what we think of as U.S. airlines.

  • The obligation to comply with government safety and security laws is a general exception to airlines’ obligations described in this Bill of Rights.
  • Also, some airlines are approved by DOT to use an alternative method to comply with a regulation when it provides an equivalent level of accessibility or it meets the objective of Part 382. Visit the docket for the Equivalent Alternative Determinations and Conflict of Law Waivers for more information.

Are airline contractors subject to the same obligations as airlines?

  • Airlines must make sure their contractors that provide services to the public meet regulatory obligations. Airlines are legally responsible for the action or inaction of their contractors.

My thoughts: there are several Different Air Carrier Access Act regulatory provisions, such as here, that make it crystal clear that airline responsibility to persons with disabilities is a nondelegable duty.

 1. The Right to Be Treated with Dignity and Respect.

An airline, including its employees and contractors, may not discriminate against an individual with a disability because of his or her disability.

My thoughts: what does “because of,” mean? The answer is no longer simple after Bostock, as we discussed here.

  • For example, an airline may not refuse transportation or other services because of one’s disability or resulting appearance or involuntary behavior.
  • An airline cannot require air travelers with disabilities to accept special services or subject them to restrictions that do not apply to other passengers, except passengers with disabilities may need to check-in early, provide advanced notice or documentation, or pre-board to receive certain disability-related services.
  • Airline personnel who deal with the traveling public must be trained to be aware of passengers with disabilities’ needs and how they can be accommodated safely and with dignity.
  • Airline employees and contractors must receive refresher training at least once every three years. Complaint Resolution Officials (the airlines’ experts in resolving disability-related issues) must receive refresher training annually.

My thoughts: get someone knowledgeable to do the training (providing training on ADA and on ADA related laws is a big part of my practice). Keep in mind, that there are several intersecting laws when it come to airlines dealing with people with disabilities and they are: Airline Deregulation Act, Air Carrier Access Act, Americans with Disabilities Act, and state negligence laws. It may be worthwhile for a trainer to have a background in each of these laws because the obligations vary depending upon the law involved. Making it even more complicated is that issues of preemption are also involved as a result of the Airline Deregulation Act.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.11 (General Discrimination Prohibitions); Section 382.19 (Prohibition on Refusal to Transport); Section 382.23 (Medical Certificates); Section 382.27 (Advance Notice to Obtain Certain Services); Section 382.33 (Discriminatory Restrictions); Section 382.141 (Training of Airline Personnel and Contractors); Section 382.143 (Recurrent Training of CRO).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 2. The Right to Receive Information About Services and Aircraft Capabilities and Limitations.

Airlines must provide air travelers with disabilities information upon request about the facilities and services available to them. The information must be
specific to the aircraft scheduled for the flight, unless unfeasible (for example, an unpredictable aircraft substitution occurs).

The information airlines must provide includes:

  • any aircraft-related, service-related, or other limitations on the ability to accommodate passengers with a disability, such as limitations on level-entry boarding (Airlines must provide this information to any passenger who states that he or she uses a wheelchair for boarding, even if he or she did not request the information.).
  • any limitations on the availability of storage on the aircraft
  • for assistive devices.
  • the specific location of seats with movable aisle armrests.
  • whether the aircraft has an accessible lavatory.
  • the types of services that are not available on the flight.

Reference link (14 CFR): Section 382.41 (Advance Information).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 3. The Right to Receive Information in an Accessible Format.

An airline’s primary website must be accessible if the airline uses an aircraft with more than 60 seats. In addition, airlines must ensure that automated kiosks they install after December 2016 at U.S. airports with 10,000 or more enplanements per year are an accessible model, until 25% of kiosks at each airport location are the accessible model.

My thoughts: we discussed this issue in this blog entry, here.

Passengers who identify as needing visual or hearing assistance must receive prompt access to the same trip information as other passengers at the gate, ticket area, customer service desk, and on the aircraft (so long as it does not interfere with airline employees’ safety duties).

My thoughts: with respect to the Deaf, deaf, and hard of hearing communities, I can assure you that this is simply not happening, especially with respect to the aircraft (don’t even get me started on the lack of captioning with respect to the behind the seat viewing options), if my experience flying recently is any indication.

Airlines must train personnel to recognize requests for communication accommodation. The personnel must be trained to use the most common methods for communicating with individuals who are blind, deaf, or hard of hearing that are readily available, such as writing notes, for example. Personnel must also be trained to use established means for communicating with deaf-blind passengers when they are available, such as passing out Braille cards if available, reading an information sheet that a passenger provides, or communicating through an interpreter, for example.

My thoughts: I simply do not understand the focus on deaf-blind in this regulation apart from other disabilities that have communication challenges. Perhaps, DOT was rather inartfully trying to say that airlines must also be aware of deaf-blind passengers and their needs, which is absolutely true. It could have been phrased a lot better.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.43 (Website Accessibility); Section 382.53 (Information for Blind, Deaf, or Hard of Hearing at Airports); Section 382.57 (Kiosk Accessibility); Section 382.119 (Information for Blind, Deaf, or Hard of Hearing on Aircraft); Section 382.141 (Training of Airline Personnel and Contractors).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 4. The Right to Accessible Airport Facilities.

Airlines and U.S. airport operators are both responsible for the accessibility of airport facilities. The Air Carrier Access (ACAA) and Department’s implementing regulation in 14 CFR Part 382 cover airlines’ obligations. Various other federal statutes and regulations apply to U.S. airport operators, for example, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and their implementing regulations. Airlines and airport operators have concurrent obligations to ensure accessibility of airport facilities.

My thoughts: airports are invariably but not always owned and operated by nonfederal governmental entities. As such, most airports, which are owned by nonfederal governmental entities, are subject to title II of the ADA and to §504 of the Rehabilitation Act because they take federal funds. If it is a private airport, the airport would be subject to title III of the ADA and to §504 of the Rehabilitation Act as you have to assume a private airport would take federal funds. The obligations of the title II or title III entity are nondelegable, as we discussed in this blog entry and in this blog entry.

This Bill of Rights describes the obligations of airlines under the ACAA. In general, airlines must ensure that terminal facilities that they own, lease, or control are readily accessible and usable by passengers with disabilities at U.S. airports, and readily usable at foreign airports. Airports are responsible for ensuring compliance of facilities that they own, operate, or lease to other parties, including airlines.

Airlines must ensure an accessible route between the gate and the aircraft boarding location. When level-entry boarding is not available, such as boarding via a jet bridge, airlines and U.S. airports must ensure ramps or mechanical lifts are available to service most flights. Airlines, in cooperation with airport operators, must also provide service animal relief areas at the airport.

My thoughts: I am consulting on several cases where a person with a disability under the care of an airline suffers a personal injury. When that happens, you have to deal with the intersection of the Airline Deregulation Act, the ADA, the Air Carrier Access Act, and state negligence laws. There are also issues of preemption, so it can all get pretty complicated.

Reference links (14 CFR, unless otherwise noted): Section 382.51 (Accessibility of Airport Facilities); Section 382.95 (Assistance With Respect to Boarding and Deplaning); Section 382.99 (Agreements Between Airlines and Airports); Section 382.101 (Other Boarding and Deplaning Assistance); 28 CFR 35 (Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Disability in State and Local Government Services); 49 CFR 27 (Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Disability-Receipt of Federal Financial Assistance); 49 CFR 37 (Transportation Services for Individuals with Disabilities).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 5. The Right to Assistance at Airports.

Passengers with disabilities must be provided prompt and timely enplaning and deplaning assistance, upon request, from properly trained airline personnel.

 

My thoughts: the Air Carrier Access Act regulations, such as here for example, make it quite clear that “upon request,” is not parenthetical. Also, the phrasing is confusing because it is upon request of the person with a disability and not the airline or its subcontractor’s personnel that is the critical question.

 

This must include:

  • the services of personnel and the use of ground wheelchairs, accessible motorized carts, boarding wheelchairs, on-board wheelchairs, and ramps or mechanical lifts, as needed.
  • assistance with moving from the curb to the departing flight, assistance with transportation between gates to make connections, and assistance with moving from the arriving flight to the curb for pick-up.
  • assistance with accessing key functional areas of the terminal such as the ticket counter or baggage claim, or to a restroom entrance (if time allows).
  • escorting a passenger with a service animal to an animal relief area at a U.S. airport.

Passengers who request assistance in advance of arriving at the airport need to identify to airline personnel once they arrive at the airport or the gate to receive the assistance.

Airlines cannot require the passenger to accept a specific form of assistance that he or she does not request (ex: requiring a wheelchair when a sight guide was requested).

In addition, the airline cannot leave a passenger unattended for more than 30 minutes in a wheelchair or other device, in which the passenger is not independently mobile.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.11 (General Discrimination Prohibitions); Section 382.91 (Assistance in Moving Within Terminal); Section 382.95 (Assistance With Respect to Boarding and Deplaning); Section 382.103 (Prohibition on Unattended Immobile Wheelchair Passenger).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 6. The Right to Assistance on the Aircraft.

Airlines must allow a passenger with a disability who self-identifies at the gate as needing additional time or assistance to board, stow accessibility equipment, or be seated, the opportunity to board before all other passengers.

  • Except, an airline with an open seating policy has been approved by DOT to accommodate extra-time passengers after an initial group of passengers have boarded, but early in the boarding process.

Passengers with disabilities must be provided prompt and timely boarding and deplaning assistance, upon request, from properly trained airline personnel.

  • This includes assistance with moving to and from seats.
  • If level loading bridges are not available, a lifting device must be provided to assist persons with limited mobility safely on and off the aircraft at most U.S. airports, except when boarding smaller aircraft (less than 19 seats).
  • For smaller aircraft and non-primary U.S. airports or foreign airports, airlines must ensure boarding and deplaning assistance by any available means acceptable to the passenger.
  • However, airlines must never hand-carry a passenger (directly pick up a passenger’s body in the arms of airline personnel) on or off an aircraft, except in an emergency.

Once a passenger with a disability has boarded, airlines must provide assistance, if requested, such as:

  • moving to or from the lavatory, including using an on-board chair to assist, if requested.
  • stowing and retrieving carry-on items, including assistive devices.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.93 (Preboarding); Section 382.95 (Assistance With Respect to Boarding and Deplaning); Section 382.101 (Other Boarding and Deplaning Assistance); Section 382.111 (Services Required On the Aircraft); Section 382.113 (Services Airlines are Not Required to Provide On the Aircraft).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 7. The Right to Travel with an Assistive Device or Service Animal.

Traveling with Assistive Devices on Aircraft

Airlines must allow assistive devices as carry-ons in the cabin free of charge consistent with safety rules.

  • This includes medical devices and/or a personal amount of medication that assist the passenger with his or her disability.
  • Assistive devices must not count against the passenger’s carry-on limit.
  • Priority in-cabin stowage (either a closet or a row of seats designated for seat strapping) must be available for at least one normal-sized collapsible manual wheelchair in any aircraft with 100 or more passenger seats.
  • Airlines that use seat strapping should provide space for at least two of these wheelchairs if stowing the second wheelchair would not displace passengers.
  • The priority stowage requirements do not apply to older aircraft.

Manual wheelchairs that cannot be transported in the cabin must be transported in the cargo compartment consistent with safety and security requirements. Airlines must accept a battery powered wheelchair, if it fits in the cargo compartment and can be transported consistent with safety and security requirements. Airlines must also provide for the checking and timely return of assistive devices at the gate for use in the terminal. Should an airline lose, damage, or destroy the wheelchair or other assistive device, the airline must provide compensation in an amount up to the original purchase price of the wheelchair or device.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.67 (Priority Stowage of Wheelchairs In-Cabin); 382.121 (Assistive Devices In-Cabin); Section 382.125 (Stowage of Assistive Devices In Cargo); Section 382.131 (Liability for Loss, Damage, or Delay of Assistive Devices).

Traveling with Service Animals

Airlines must permit a service dog to accompany a passenger with a disability in the aircraft cabin unless:

  • the dog poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others;
  • the dog causes a significant disruption or misbehaves in the cabin or at an airport gate area;
  • the dog’s carriage would violate a U.S. or foreign law;
  • current DOT forms weren’t provided as required by the airline for the trip.

A decision by airline personnel to refuse transportation of a service dog with the passenger must be based on an individualized and objective assessment of the dog that considers the nature of the risk and the likelihood that harm will actually, or continue to, occur. The assessment should also consider whether mitigations are available.

Airlines cannot deny transportation of the service dog if there are means that would mitigate the problem.

Reference link (14 CFR): Sections 382.72 -382.80 (Service Animals).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

My thoughts: we discussed the DOT final rule when it comes to animals on airplanes here.

 8. The Right to Receive Seating Accommodations.

Airlines must provide specific seats to the following passengers who identify to airline personnel as needing the seat, if the seat exists on the same class of service on the aircraft:

  • Movable Aisle Armrest–When the passenger uses an aisle chair to board and cannot transfer readily over a fixed aisle armrest.
  • Bulkhead Seat or Other Seat–When the passenger travels with a service animal that is best accommodated at a particular seat.
  • Greater Leg Room–When the passenger has a fused or immobilized leg.
  • Adjoining Seat–For a companion providing a certain type of assistance, such as:
    • A personal care attendant who performs a function that is not required to be performed by airline personnel, for example assisting a passenger with a disability with eating;
    • A reader for a passenger who is blind or low vision;
    • An interpreter for a passenger who is deaf or hard of hearing; or
    • A safety assistant if a passenger with a disability cannot assist with their own evacuation.

For passengers not specified above, airlines must provide a seat assignment that best accommodates his or her disability if the passenger meets the airline’s procedures.

Airlines must provide seating accommodations using one of three methods: the block method, the priority method, or preboarding (if the airline does not provide advance seat assignments). Visit our Seating Accommodation Methods page to learn more about these seating methods and for the seating methods of the largest U.S. airlines and their operating partners, which account for approximately 95 percent of domestic passenger air traffic. Information regarding seating methods of certain foreign air carriers is also provided.

Reference link (14 CFR): Sections 382.81-382.87 (Seating Accommodations).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 9. The Right to Accessible Aircraft Features.

New aircraft delivered to U.S. airlines after April 1992 and to foreign airlines after May 2010 must have accessible features that include:

  • Movable aisle armrests on half of the aisle seats, if the aircraft has 30 or more seats.
    • DOT has approved some airlines to meet the purpose of this requirement by alternative means that provide substantially the same or greater accessibility to passengers with disabilities.
  • Priority stowage space for wheelchairs in the cabin for aircraft with 100 or more seats.
  • At least one accessible lavatory, if the aircraft has more than one aisle.
  • An on-board wheelchair, if the aircraft has an accessible lavatory, or the passenger gives the airline advance notice that he or she can use an inaccessible lavatory and needs an on-board chair to reach it.

Airlines with older aircraft with 30 or more seats that replace the aisle seats, must ensure half of these seats have movable aisle armrests. Also, if an airline replaces a lavatory on a twin-aisle aircraft, there must be an accessible lavatory.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.61 (Movable Aisle Armrests); Section 382.63 (Lavatories); Section 382.65 (On-Board Wheelchairs).

Click Back to The Bill of Rights Section

 10. The Right to Resolution of a Disability-Related Issue.

Airlines must make available a Complaint Resolution Official (CRO) in a timely manner, this may be by phone.

  • The CRO should be trained as an expert in resolving disability-related issues and be able to resolve disability-related issues on the spot.
    • Passengers with disabilities who are not satisfied with air travel services, may file a complaint with the airline or DOT. Complaints concerning issues under the airport’s responsibility can be filed with the airport, FAA or DOJ.
  • Airlines must respond and directly address the disability related issues in your complaint in writing within 30 days, but airlines are not required to address complaints sent more than 45 days after the incident unless the complaint is referred to the airline by DOT.
  • DOT will refer all disability-related complaints it receives within 6 months of the incident for response by the appropriate carrier.
  • DOT investigates all disability-related complaints it receives to determine whether a violation of the Air Carrier Access Act occurred.
  • Passengers with disabilities who have pressing questions about their rights should ask to speak with the airline’s CRO. Airlines must have a CRO available at each airport they serve during all times the airline is operating at that airport. Passengers may also contact the DOT Disability Hotline at 1-800-778-4838. The hours for the hotline are 8:30am to 5:00pm Monday-Friday.

Reference links (14 CFR): Section 382.151 (CROs); Section 382.155 (Carrier Responses to Complaints); Section 382.159 (Filing a Complaint with DOT).

 

My thoughts: as we have discussed previously in the blog, here for example, no private cause of action exists for violations of the Air Carrier Access Act regulations.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/linMBLN
via Abogado Aly Website

Court Finds Declaratory Judgment Action, Not Trespass to Try Title

Co-author Trevor Lawhorn

SM Energy Co. v. Union Pac. R.R. Co. considers a question frequently asked in Texas suits affecting title: When is a suit a trespass to try title action and not a declaratory judgment action?

The dispute

SM Energy and Union Pacific are parties to three oil and gas leases covering lands in Howard County. Each lease contains the same forum-selection clause providing for exclusive venue in “… Omaha, Nebraska and no other place.”

Union Pacific demanded that SM pay damages for breaching the leases. SM failed to pay in time but later tendered the damages and identified other leases in violation of a most-favored-nations clause. Union Pacific eventually accepted tender of SM’s offer, but maintained that SM owed $5mm+ in liquidated damages.

SM sued Union Pacific in Howard County asserting SM’s ownership of the leasehold estate and claiming that Union Pacific unlawfully dispossessed SM of its right to possession. Union Pacific responded with a motion to dismiss for improper venue, arguing that Omaha was the proper forum, citing the forum-selection clause and Texas’ “major transactions” venue rule (Civil Practice and Remedies Code §15.020).

The trial court granted Union Pacific’s motion. SM appealed and argued that the trial court erred in enforcing the forum-selection clause and erred by finding that Nebraska was a proper forum to litigate the dispute.

The appeal

The Court of Appeals affirmed.

SM asserted that its trespass-to-try-title action could only be litigated in Texas; therefore a Texas court has exclusive subject-matter jurisdiction.  The Court considered the substance of SM’s petition and saw a claim for declaratory judgment to determine SM’s obligations, not trespass-to-try-title. SM pleaded certain elements of trespass-to-try-title but its claims of dispossession were, in substance, dependent on an initial determination that the liquidated damages provision was unenforceable.

Second, the Court disagreed that SM’s claim was a suit to remove a cloud on title. SM could not show that Union Pacific’s claim was invalid or unenforceable, which is a prerequisite to a suit to remove a cloud on title.

Third, the Court disagreed with SM’s contention that enforcement of the forum selection clause would violate Texas’s public policy against piecemeal litigation. For all intents and purposes, the claimant was Union Pacific because Union Pacific is the party asserting that SM breached the leases.

The trial court also erred by finding that Nebraska was a proper forum to litigate the dispute—The 640-acre lease met the requirements of a “major transaction” as described by the venue rule. This question turned on whether the lease evidenced consideration exceeding $1mm for purposes of the statute. The lease failed to state consideration exceeding $1mm, but related documents could be considered as evidence of a major transaction. One week after execution of the lease, Union Pacific confirmed to SM’s predecessor-in-interest that the original lessee paid Union Pacific a lease bonus of $2.4mm. The court considered confirmation to be a separate instrument that was executed at the same time, for the same purpose, and in the course of the same transaction such that the documents could be analyzed together.

Takeaways

  • Courts will look to the substance, not the form, of a party’s pleadings to determine whether a claim is for trespass-to-try title or declaratory judgment.
  • When the issue of dispossession of title is secondary to the determination of the breach or enforceability of a contract, courts may find the case to be for declaratory judgment, not trespass-to-try-title action.
  • The lease and separate documents reflecting payments that relate to the lease may be construed together for purposes of establishing the value of the lease.

RIP Sonny Corleone and Paulie Walnuts.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/ye9gWSn
via Abogado Aly Website

Thursday, July 14, 2022

Latinx still making firsts

Now in the third decade of the new century, persons of color continue to break barriers. Although Texas has the second highest Latinx population in the United States, prior to 2021, it did not have a Latinx judge organization like those found in California, New York, and Illinois. That barrier was broken on May 5, 2021, through the creation of Texas Latinx Judges, or TLJ. One of the first associations of its kind in Texas, TLJ is a nonpartisan, nonprofit association focused on empowering current and future Latinx judges. It fosters a pipeline for future Latinx judges with the goal of enhancing diversity, inclusion, and excellence in the judiciary so that equal justice is provided to all.

Another legal first in 2021, El Paso lawyer Sylvia Borunda Firth became the first Latina to become president of the State Bar of Texas. Borunda Firth’s experience as a former city attorney and her service in different leadership roles with the State Bar helped her garner support from lawyers statewide during the 2020 president-elect race. When elected, Borunda Firth stated, “It is an honor and a big responsibility to represent my culture and my gender … and bring more diversity to the State Bar.”

As State Bar president-elect, Firth created a 15-member Task Force on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion to study and propose actions to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion in the administration of justice and the practice of law. Recommendations were made relating to providing pipeline programs and resources aimed at improving diversity, equity, and inclusion.

TLJ is also committed to shaping the future of equal justice in Texas by increasing the advancement and the number of Latinx judges in Texas. TLJ encourages lawyers to join TLJ and demystifies the processes of being elected or appointed to a judicial position. TLJ also hosts events for law students across the state. TLJ teaches students about the judiciary, shares distinct paths that individuals have taken to become jurists, and encourages students to consider the possibility that they too can be judges.

TLJ’s founding officers and board members are diverse jurists from across the state: Judge Lesley Briones (president and former Harris County judge of County Court at Law No. 4); Judge Victor Villarreal (president-elect and Webb County judge of County Court at Law II); Judge Maria Salas-Mendoza (secretary and judge of the 120th District Court in El Paso County); Chief Justice Dori Contreras (treasurer and justice of the 13th Court of Appeals); and board members Judge Antonia Arteaga, of Bexar County’s 57th District Court; Justice Gina Benavides, of the 13th Court of Appeals; and retired Judge Orlinda Naranjo, former judge of Travis County 419th District Court.

These legal firsts in 2021 will help shape justice in Texas for decades to come.

Judge Orlinda Naranjo retired after 24 years on the bench in Travis County. She presided over the 419th District Court for 12 years and County Court at Law #2 for 12 years, where she heard civil, criminal, and family law cases. During Naranjo’s tenure on the bench, she was appointed by the Texas Supreme Court to several statewide positions including the Texas Judicial Council, the State Commission on Judicial Conduct, and the Texas Indigent Defense Task Force. She is a founding member and board member of Texas Latinx Judges.

Judge Victor Villarreal presides over Webb County Court at Law II, which was designated in 2019, under his administration, as a Judicial Center of Excellence by the Texas Judicial Council. In addition to hearing civil, criminal, probate, guardianship, mental health, family law, and juvenile cases, he is the administrative judge of the Webb County Courts at Law and president-elect of Texas Latinx Judges.

 

 

 



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/8j7wm2c
via Abogado Aly Website

WhatsApp and its divorce relationship?

Social media can be a good thing for many people. Being able to connect with friends and family across the world brings us closer together from a relationship standpoint. We know that the pandemic caused and is still causing great disruption to how many of us socialize with one another and generally lead our lives. There was some thought at the very beginning of the pandemic (if you care to think back to that time) that online and virtual meetings and interactions would become the norm due to concerns about transmitting the virus to one another.

Fortunately, due to several factors, that did not turn out to be the case. As time has marched on since March 2020, we have seen that travel has increased and that most of us are more comfortable with living our lives away from screens and digital get-togethers. However, there will always be a place for social media in our lives. This was true before the pandemic and is true now. What we need to figure out is how social media use can be beneficial for us and how it could potentially hurt our lives. Then we can pick our spots and find the best of both worlds when it comes to communicating with one another.

What is WhatsApp?

WhatsApp Messenger is an internationally available instant messaging and voiceover service. You can use WhatsApp to send text and voice messages in addition to sending video calls and documents to other people from cell phones, tablets, and desktop computers. All you need to sign up for the WhatsApp app is a cell phone number. Since its creation back in 2009, WhatsApp has taken off in terms of popularity and is now in use across the globe. People everyday use WhatsApp to send secure messages to other users. Users can also create groups to discuss topics of their choosing much like on a traditional social media website.

For our purposes in today’s blog post from the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, this is all we need to establish about WhatsApp. If you are coming across our post and have additional questions about the application, then I would recommend simply searching the term on your favorite search engine. You can learn much more about WhatsApp, its history, and any other information that you could ever hope to gain. However, for today in this blog post, we will leave it at that and move on to discuss how WhatsApp, and social media in general, can have a significant relationship with marital issues and divorce.

Where is my spouse?

It used to be that if your spouse did not come home immediately after work you could assume that he or she had gone out for a drink with co-workers or something like that. Currently, you do not need to wonder. There are many ways to keep up with your spouse’s activities away from home simply by taking advantage of the technology that we have literally at our fingertips. Their cell phone has GPS tracking where you can get up-to-second updates on where he or she is located. This is a great way to keep track of your kids if they have cell phones but works in the same way for spouses.

WhatsApp can allow you to track the whereabouts of your spouse, as well. You may not be surprised to learn that social media use can be a direct cause of divorce. What may have started as an innocent escape into their past may have led to your spouse becoming more and more engaged in social media use when it comes to connecting with former partners or new relationships. There is something of a disconnect that many people experience when connecting with someone online. What may feel inappropriate for in-person behavior could seem like no big deal on the internet. However, things can quickly spiral out of control and can lead to a relationship that destroys your marriage. It is easy to say this but much more difficult to stop the behavior in many cases.

Even if your spouse is not using social media to cheat, simply knowing that he or she uses various social media platforms can be enough to cause suspicion. This is true especially if your spouse is secretive about their social media use or is not always honest with you about their habits or other behavior. Having an open and honest flow of communication with your spouse is critical to being able to understand how he or she is using social media and whether it may become a problem for your marriage now or down the line.

If you have concerns about your spouse’s use of social media, it is a good idea to pursue those concerns directly with him or her. Do not wait around and let that concern fester. Talk to him or her about their use of social media before it becomes a problem for your marriage. The use of social media by your spouse may be completely benign. However, it could be something more especially if you do not ask questions about it when you believe that it is becoming an issue.

Using social media to spy on your spouse is not what I am talking about. Being sneaky creates an atmosphere of distrust in a relationship. That can spiral out of control quickly and put you in a position where neither of you trusts one other. From that point, it can be difficult to ever achieve a healthy relationship. Rather, you should ask questions about social media use and be ready to listen to your spouse. If he or she refuses to engage with you or continues to be secretive it may be time to bring in outside help to facilitate discussions on appropriate social media use and boundaries. A counselor, therapist, or even a person that you two mutually trust could be helpful in this regard.

Trying to meet an unrealistic standard for relationship happiness

Every marriage has its struggles from time to time. No marriage, no matter how perfect it appears, functions exactly the way that the spouses want it to all the time. Every married person will tell you that their relationship takes work. However, if you were to go on social media you would tend to believe that marriage is a walk in the park for many people and that life is only rosy photos and happy status updates. Is this what you are seeing when you go online, as well?

If so, then you need to consider how social media distorts reality when it comes to how people are living their lives. While some people experience relatively smooth waters when it comes to relationships, most of us have ups and downs that can be tough to work through. I know that sometimes marriage can seem like it is a constant struggle when it comes to kids, finances, family issues, and the general state of living with another adult who has their own opinions about life and how best to live it. As a result, marriage brings about daily challenges that need to be faced head-on and not avoided.

When you see constantly happy faces on social media from friends and family your reaction does not need to be: “What’s wrong with my marriage?” Rather, you should first appreciate the happiness you see from others while understanding that the photo you are looking at is a snapshot in time. It is not a video of their life over a long period. That moment may have been a happy one and the reason why a photo was taken. However, life is a 24-hour event each day. That happy moment may have been followed or preceded by more mundane or even difficult times.

Assuming that the grass is greener in a different set of circumstances or even in a different relationship can be a dangerous course to pursue if you are basing that assumption on social media use. The way that you interact with people online is probably not the way that you would interact with them in person. What can begin as an easy way to communicate with someone from your past can quickly find you face to face with that person. From there a wide range of outcomes are possible which can be detrimental to your marriage. Rather than put yourself in a position where you are in over your head when it comes to starting a relationship that you were not prepared for, you should consider why you started communicating with him or her in the first place.

If you started a chat with an old friend as an escape from the difficulties of your marriage, then you should accept this. Many people like to set aside difficult feelings in hopes of reviving past relationships that make them feel better about their current lives. This is a dangerous path to go down considering that you cannot expect to make improvements in your current life if you continually slip back into old relationships. The truth of the matter is that relationships tend to end for a reason. If you have an old relationship that is now becoming a current relationship you should examine why that is. Sometimes people from your past can come back into your life for a good reason that is organic. Other times we can force old relationships back into our lives for reasons that are much less desirable in the long term.

The bottom line when it comes to social media and how we view our marriage is that it is easy to get an extremely distorted view of things if we only interact with others digitally. When you build real relationships with other people it allows you to gain a better understanding of how relationships truly work. Real life is a movie with ups, downs, and all the nuances that comes with being a real human being. Social media is a snapshot of time. Do not be fooled or allow yourself to be fooled by social media when comes to viewing the relationships of others.

What can you do to decrease the likelihood of divorce due to social media usage?

To think that a divorce is likely because your spouse uses social media frequently would be a huge mistake. I do not want to give you the idea that simply because you or your spouse utilize social media regularly that there is a problem in your relationship. Again, it is possible to use social media responsibly. However, if you believe that your spouse’s, or your own, use of social media is becoming a point of contention in your marriage then there are some steps that you can take to address those concerns.

The first thing that you can do is to determine whether you have the skills necessary to artfully discuss these topics with your spouse. This requires a certain degree of self-reflection and honesty that can be difficult to possess. If you think that you may not have the communication skills or patience to discuss these topics with your spouse, then you may want to bring in someone like a marriage counselor or therapist into the picture. Usually, this would be done after first discussing the subject with your spouse to gauge their willingness to participate in the conversation.

If you do wish to start a conversation it would be a good idea to do so without distraction. For example, starting to talk with your spouse about concerns over social media while you are scrolling through your phone can be a self-defeating exercise. Rather, it would seem to be a good idea to put your phones away, turn off the television and spend some time focusing on the issues of your marriage together- free from distraction. This is a much more hospitable environment for accomplishing something meaningful when it comes to your marriage.

Next, you can discuss appropriate boundaries when it comes to the use of social media. Many times, your spouse may be unaware that you are uncomfortable with their use of social media or that the types of conversations that they are having are inappropriate. In situations like that, you can begin to address those problems with your spouse patiently. Point out how their social media use is impacting you and what he or they can do to help reduce strife in your marriage. You may be surprised to learn just how receptive he or she is to your ideas and concerns.

You may be surprised to learn how simple it is to get in contact with a good marriage and family therapist. Finding a therapist could involve you contacting your health insurance provider to obtain a list of providers that are covered by your health insurance. Due to the magic of the internet, you can find therapists and counselors who are in other places and can meet with you virtually. Also, I imagine that many therapists can meet with you in person here locally as concerns over in-person therapy sessions have lessened recently.

Additionally, a leader of your religious congregation may also be able to assist you in obtaining therapy. This may be through offering you therapy to him or herself. Or there may be a parishioner who can offer their services and who is a therapist. Many times, these folks would be willing to meet with you on a reduced fee or even a free basis. In some instances, you may be more comfortable with speaking to a person like this who shares your religious beliefs and practices.

the bottom line in what I am telling you is that there are options for you to pursue when it to comes to remedying any issues when it comes to your personal life and marriage. Communication is the central point in this discussion. If you are willing to talk through the problems in your marriage, then you have an opportunity to solve those problems constructively. I have discovered in my time as an attorney that it is important to be intentional and to develop a plan when it comes to solving any problem period you may have wandered into problems with social media and the Internet regarding your marriage, but it is difficult to impossible to just wander out of those problems. Rather, you need to be able to take your plan and implemented it as best as possible to salvage your marriage.

If you believe that you have worked as hard as you can in that you and your spouse are at a dead end when it comes to trying to save your marriage, then it may be time to consult with an attorney to learn more about your options regarding a divorce. We thank you for joining us in our blog today and hope that you will consider the Law Office of Bryan Fagan regarding that subject.

Questions about the material contained in today’s blog post? Contact the Law Office of Bryan Fagan

If you have any questions about the material contained in today’s blog post, please do not hesitate to contact the Law Office of Bryan Fagan. Our licensed family law attorneys offer free of charge consultations six days a week in person, over the phone, and via video. These consultations are a great way for you to learn more about the world of Texas family law as well as about how your family circumstances may be impacted by the filing of a divorce or child custody case.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/IbdaKq8
via Abogado Aly Website

Wednesday, July 13, 2022

Are you suspicious of hidden assets in your divorce?

Both spouses should be forthcoming with their financial details when dividing property during a divorce. However, it’s not given that your spouse will be honest. They may fail to disclose some assets, intentionally or not, since they do not want to lose them when dividing the marital estate.

Hiding assets during a divorce is not only against the law but also denies you a fair share of what you deserve from the divorce. If you notice something amiss, you ought to protect your financial interests.

How assets are hidden

Failure to disclose assets is just one of the many ways of hiding assets during property division. You should be wary of the other ways assets can be hidden. Some of the red flags include:

  • Irregular payments or cash flow in the months preceding the divorce
  • Property transfers to family or friends
  • Under-reporting income earned
  • Undervaluing assets
  • A change in the address where financial information is sent
  • Changes in passwords to accounts or investments held by your spouse, among others

All these can point to something underhanded, and you should act fast before it’s too late.

What should you do?

If you discover any financial anomalies by your soon-to-be-ex regarding the divorce, it is crucial to bring them to the court’s attention. However, before sounding the siren, it is important to have evidence of your claims, such as bank records or financial statements.

There are many ways of uncovering hidden assets, but it is wise to get professional help throughout the process so you can best protect your interests – and your future.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/WUG4Y62
via Abogado Aly Website

Texas Supreme Court: Texas Central Has Eminent Domain Power for High Speed Rail

 

In a case we’ve been closely following, Miles v. Texas Central Railroad & Infrastructure, Inc., the Texas Supreme Court held that Texas Central does have the right to exercise eminent domain power in building the high speed rail from Dallas to Houston.

Background

This case revolves around the proposed high-speed electric-powered passenger train that would run between Dallas and Houston. In 2012, TXHS Railroad, Inc. was formed and in 2015, the company changed its name to Texas Central Railroad & Infrastructure, Inc. (“Texas Central”) with a purpose to “plan, build, maintain, and operate an interurban electric railroad.”  In 2017, Integrated Texas Logistics (ITL) was formed to “construct, acquire, maintain, or operate lines of electric railway…” and “to operate and transact business as a railroad company…”

In 2015, Texas Central sent Mr. Miles a packet including details about the project, an outline of the survey process, an invitation to open house meetings, and a survey permission form.  Mr. Miles refused to sign the survey permission form and refused to grant Texas Central access to survey his land.

Mr. Miles filed suit, seeking a declaration that Texas Central could not conduct the type of survey requested on the permission form as the form exceeded certain provisions in the Texas Transportation Code related to railroads and interurban electric railways.  Essentially, Mr. Miles did not argue that a “railroad company” or an “interurban electric railway” could not use eminent domain power; only that Texas Central and ITL did not meet the statutory definition of a “railroad company” or an “interurban electric railway.”  Mr. Miles based this on the facts that Texas Central owned no trains or railroad tracks, had constructed no train stations, had obtained only a small portion of the financing necessary for the project, and that ITL had no employees, officers, or office space independent of Texas Central.  Further, Mr. Miles argued that the “interurban electric railways” referenced by statute were obsolete for over 70 years and the statute was not intended to apply to a high speed rail.

Texas Central responded, seeking its own declaratory judgment that it was a “railroad company” and an “interurban electric railway” under the Texas Transportation Code with the right to conduct survey examinations as such. ITL intervened seeking the same declaration against Mr. Miles.  The entities based their argument on Texas Central’s expenditure of over $125 million on the project, engaging 100 technical experts and 200 employees and contractors, completing over 2,000 surveys, obtaining hundreds of option contracts to purchase the necessary land, a signed agreement with Amtrak to connect with Amtrak’s interstate rail system, retaining an engineering firm and railway company that have experience with building and operating high speed rails, and working for years to secure required federal and state permits.

Applicable Law

There are two statutes central to this case.

First, the Texas Transportation Code Section 81.002 defines a “railroad company” as “(1) a railroad incorporated before September 1, 2007 or (2) any other legal entity operating a railroad, including an entity organized under the Texas Business Corporation Act or the Texas Corporation Law provisions of the Business Organizations Code.”  Since both entities were incorporated after 2007, it is only the second clause at issue.  A “railroad” is defined by Texas Transportation Code Section 199.002(a)(1) as “an enterprise created and operated to carry passengers, freight, or both on a fixed track. The term includes all real estate and interests in real estate, equipment, machinery, materials, structures, buildings, stations, facilities, and other improvements that are necessary to, or for the benefit of, the enterprise.”  A railroad company has the right to use eminent domain authority  per Texas Transportation Code Section 112.002(5).

Second, an “interurban electric railway company” is a “corporation chartered under the laws of this state to conduct and operate an electric railway between two municipalities in this state.”  See Tex. Transportation Code Section 131.011.  Companies meeting this definition and have the purpose of transporting freight, passengers, or both freight and passengers are granted the power of eminent domain.  See Tex. Transportation Code Section 131.012.

Lower Court Rulings

The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment on these issues.  The trial court sided with Mr. Miles, declaring that neither Texas Central nor ITL were “railroad companies” or “interurban electric railways.” Mr. Miles was also awarded attorney’s fees.  Texas Central and ITL appealed.

The Corpus Christi Court of Appeals reversed, finding that Texas Central and ITL were both “railroad companies” and “interurban electric railways” per Texas statute.  Thus, the companies do have the right to use eminent domain power.  [Read blog post here.]

Mr. Miles sought review from the Texas Supreme Court. Initially, the Court declined to hear the case, but then granted Mr. Miles’ motion for reconsideration.  During briefing, the State of Texas wrote a brief supporting Mr. Miles arguing that Texas Central should not have eminent domain power.  Oral argument was held on January 11.

Supreme Court Majority Opinion

The Texas Supreme Court affirmed in a 5-3 decision.  The majority opinion was authored by Justice Lehrmann and joined by Chief Justice Hecht, and Justices Boyd, Busby, and Young. [Read Majority Opinion here.]

Interestingly, the majority began by noting “it is important to recognize what this case is about and what it is not about.  The case involves the interpretation of statutes relating to eminent domain; it does not ask us to opine about whether high-speed rail between Houston and Dallas is a good idea or whether the benefits of the proposed rail service outweigh its detriments. The narrow issue presented is whether the two private entities behind the project have been statutorily granted the power of eminent domain, a power otherwise reserved to the State and its political subdivisions because of the extraordinary intrusion on private-property rights that the exercise of such authority entails.”

Interurban electric railway company

The Court tuned first to the statute granting eminent domain authority to interurban electric railway companies.  “Miles asserts that modern high-speed rail cannot be ‘shoehorned’ into the concept of the interurban electric railway the Legislature envisioned…in 1907.”  Miles argues that the concept of an interurban electric railway is a technical term referring specifically to the single-car interurban electric railways that grew out of the trolley car and ran through Texas in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.   The Court disagreed.

“Viewed as a whole, Chapter 131 is simply not limited in the way that Miles and the dissent contend.”  First, the statute does not limit the speed a train may reach, size of train, or distance between municipalities the railway connects.  Second, the Court points to statutory provisions within Chapter 131 discussing 200 foot right of ways to build railways and the ability to take additional land necessary to properly construct and secure railways as contemplating projects of similar scale as the Texas Central high speed rail. Third, the statute contemplates a railway being able to cross a major body of water and build the necessary infrastructure to do so.   In summary, “we do not read Chapter 131 to implicitly place the above-described limitations on the statute’s scope–regarding speed, size, and distance–that the Legislature easily could have placed expressly but chose not to.”

Next, the Court addressed Mr. Miles’ argument that when the statute was originally enacted in 1907, the modern version of the high speed rail had not been developed and, therefore, it cannot apply.  This is based on the concept that when a statute contains undefined terms, courts should consider the terms’ ordinary meaning when the statute was passed.  The Court disagreed for several reasons.  First, the Court does not seek to determine the meaning of an undefined term; the statute expressly defines an interurban electric railway company.  Second, even if the term were undefined, the statute does not grant eminent domain only to an “interurban electric railway company.”  Instead, it grants the authority more broadly to a “corporation chartered for the purpose of constructing, acquiring, maintaining, or operating lines of electric railway between municipalities in this state for the transportation of freight, passengers, or both freight and passengers.”  There is no dispute about the ordinary meaning of any of these words and, therefore, the historic meaning was not relevant.

Then, the Court noted that it has “long interpreted statutes, including eminent domain statutes, to embrace later-developed technologies when the statutory text allows.”  For example, in interpreting eminent domain statutes for telegraph companies, the Court held those statutes applied to telephone companies as well even though the legislature likely did not have telephones in mind when it used the word “telegraph.”  Thus, although the 1907 Legislature would not have considered a high speed rail, had that technology become available the next year, no one would have thought the Legislature needed to pass another statute to accommodate it.   This is not unlimited, the Court notes.  For example, it says that it would not read the interurban electric railway statute to apply to steam-powered locomotive, but nothing in the language  limits applicability to the small, single train streetcar as Mr. Miles argues.

The Court then turned to Mr. Miles’ argument that the statute applies to a type of train that has been extinct in Texas since 1948. Simply put, the Court stated, “nothing in the statute limits its application in this way.”  This would have meant the statute remained on the books with no purpose for over 70 years, despite being recodified in 2009 in an attempt to eliminate repealed, duplicative, expired and executed provisions.  The Court said this statutory revision program made little sense if the interurban electric railway statute was as outdated and useless as Miles and the dissent claims.

Next, Mr. Miles cited several Transportation Code provisions that do expressly apply to a high speed rail.  The Court said it failed to see how other provisions, with different definitions, somehow indicates that the high speed rail does not fall within the scope of the electric railway definition, particularly when nothing in the provisions in inapplicable with Chapter 131.

Lastly, Mr. Miles asserted that the 1989 enactment and 1995 repeal of the High-Speed Rail Act demonstrates that Chapter 131 cannot encompass Texas Central’s proposed railway.  The Court disagreed finding that Act established a state agency to award a franchise to a private entity to build a high speed rail and gave that entity eminent domain power, essentially creating a public-private partnership.  It then dissolved that partnership, but did not purport to restrict eminent domain authority authorized under different statutes.

Thus, the Court held that Texas Central and ITL are interurban electric railways who have the power of eminent domain.

Railroad company

Although the parties raised the issue of whether Texas Central is a railroad company, and the Chief Justices’ concurrence would hold that it was, the majority held it need not address that issue.

Application of Denbury “reasonable probability” test

Even if the companies could be interurban electric railway companies with eminent domain authority, Mr. Miles argues that merely filing a charter claiming to be one is insufficient.  Relying on Texas Rice Land Partners v. Denbury Green Pipeline-Tex., LLC (Denbury 1) and  Denbury Green Pipeline-Texas, LLC v. Texas Rice Land Partners (Denbury 2), Mr. Miles argues that Texas Central and ITL must demonstrate a reasonable probability that the project will produce the public good for which the authority is sought.  Texas Central, Mr. Miles argues, has failed to do so.

The Court rejected this reading of Denbury, noting that “while both the Texas Constitution and our precedent preclude an entity from obtaining condemnation authority by checking a box, they do not support the reasonable-probability-of-completion test Miles proposes, which would constitute an unwarranted sea change in eminent domain law with far-reaching consequences.”

The Court noted that in Denbury 1, the issue involved common carrier pipelines.  The Court held that for a person intending to build a CO2 pipeline to qualify as a common carrier, there must be a reasonable probability that the pipeline will, at some point after construction, serve the public by transporting gas for one or more customers who would retain ownership or sell to customers other than the carrier.

Thus, Texas Central does not qualify for eminent domain authority by simply checking a box.  However, here, there is no argument that Texas Central was charged for the purpose of building an interurban electric railway and is engaged in activities in furtherance of that purpose. There is also no question this railway would be for a public purpose.  “Miles’s argument that the Texas Central Entities must further show a reasonable probability that the railway will successfully be completed finds no support in Denbury or the Constitution.”

The Court notes that Mr. Miles’ attempt to “contort Denbury in this way is rooted in legitimate policy justifications” to protect Texas landowners from ill-equipped entities who take land and abandon it when funding runs dry.  The Court noted, however, there are a number of protections for property owners in that situation including a number of statutory provisions listed out in the opinion on page 26.  “The constitutional and statutory provisions governing eminent domain, as a whole, reflect a balance between the rights of property owners and the benefits served by projects for which eminent domain is authorized. It is not our place to second-guess the product of that balance.”

Thus, the Court rejected Mr. Miles’ reasonable probability of completion test interpretation of Denbury.

Expiration of authority

The Texas Government Code Section 2206.101 required entities that acquired eminent domain power before December 31, 2012 to submit a letter to the comptroller.  Failure to do so resulted in the expiration of the entity’s eminent domain authority on September 1, 2013.   Texas Central was formed in December 2012, but did not amend its charter for the purpose of operating an interurban electric railway company until 2015.  Texas Central submitted a letter to the comptroller in December 2012 claiming authority as a railroad company, but not as an interurban electric railway.  Thus, Mr. Miles argues its authority under the interurban electric railway statute expired.  The Court disagreed finding that since Texas Central did not amend its charter purpose to build an interurban electric railway until 2015, its authority did not expire.

Thus, the majority affirmed the Court of Appeals decision holding that Texas Central and ITL qualify as an interurban electric railway that may utilize eminent domain authority.

Concurring Opinion (Chief Justice Hecht, joined by Justice Young)

Chief Justice Hecht wrote separately to explain why he would hold that Texas Central and ITL also qualify as “railroad companies” under the statute.  [Read concurrence here.] The statute grants eminent domain authority to a railroad incorporated before September 1, 2007 or to any legal entity operating a railroad.  Mr. Miles argued that this requires trains running on tracks.  “The chicken-and-egg logic is obvious: an entity cannot obtain a right-of-way on which to run trains on tracks without first running trains on tracks.”  Mr. Miles’ approach would essentially ban all new railways in Texas after 2007.  Nothing in the history, the concurrence notes, indicates this intent. Further, the statute allows a company to condemn right-of-ways and “roadbed” which would occur before tracks are laid.  In fact, a company may condemn before incorporating, which the concurrence reads as “before doing any business at all.”  The statute also allows condemnation necessary to build the railroad, as well as operating and running it.  This language makes clear the Legislature did not intend to limit applicability to companies with trains running on tracks.

Concurring Opinion (Justice Young)

In an opinion expressly recognizing the great power and serious impact that eminent domain can have on property owners, Justice Young wrote to make clear the presumption that if there is any doubt as to the scope of the power, the statute granting eminent domain authority is construed in favor of the landowner remains.   [Read concurring opinion here.]  Justice Young notes that eminent domain power is great, “scary” and confusing.  He notes that there are times when “no compensation can accurately value the sweat, tears, pride, love, beauty, and history that, for some property at least, is its chief value.”  It is these circumstances, he notes, that explain why courts carefully scrutinize the exercise of eminent domain authority.  This is true for government takings, and is only heightened in situations where a private entity wields eminent domain power.

He says that nothing in the majority opinion disagrees, and where the scope of the power is in doubt, statutes shall be construed in favor of landowners.  The majority applied the exacting level of scrutiny in this case.  However, there was simply no “doubt” as to whether the interurban electric railway statute applied.  “We can judicially invalidate an exercise of condemnation only upon the kind of ‘doubt’ about the scope or meaning of statutory or constitutional provisions that is textually demonstrable. Even when we would much rather the result be different, and even when we persuade ourselves that the legislature must have intended otherwise, ‘we are bound by ‘the words of the statute’ and cannot ‘rewrite those words to achieve an unstated purpose.’”

Dissenting Opinion (Justice Devine)

Justice Devine authored a dissenting opinion.  [Read opinion here.]  Justice Devine believes that this case should be construed pursuant to Section 17(b) of the Texas Constitution, which provides that “public use” does not include the taking of property…”for transfer to a private entity for the primary purpose of economic development or enhancement of tax revenues.” The Court has not addressed this section since its amendment in 2019, and “although this case presents such an opportunity, the Court squanders it.”  He notes that the parties did not raise this issue and normally courts do not consider arguments not raised, but believes that this is a time when “prudence dictates the contrary.”

Justice Devine notes that Texas Central itself recognizes the primary purpose of building the rail is for economic development and enhancement of tax revenues. In briefing, Texas Central repeatedly pointed to the economic benefit of the high speed rail including additional jobs and tax revenues.  This was exactly the concern that promoted the post-Kelo amendment to Section 17(b) of the Texas Constitution. “The Court’s holding today flies in the face of that history and proud legacy of safeguarding the sacred right of land ownership.”  Further, he notes, “the Court incentivizes private businesses—even foreign ones—to exercise eminent-domain authority over Texas landowners. But giving such power directly to a private entity is not what our forefathers intended in drafting the Texas Constitution. Nor is it what Texans intended in amending the Constitution in 2009.”

He would have applied Section 17(b) of the Texas Constitution to hold that Texas Central is not entitled to exercise eminent domain power because the requirement of ‘public use’ is not met.  He statutes that the majority opinion “advances a devastating erosion of Texas landowners’ property rights” and respectfully dissents.

Dissenting Opinion (Justice Huddle, joined by Justices Devine and Blacklock

Justice Huddle also filed a dissenting opinion.  [Read opinion here.]

The dissent notes that the majority holds that two for-profit corporations wield the power to take thousands of parcels of privately owned Texas land along the proposed route of a high speed rail they hope to someday build and operate based on a 115-year-old statute governing sisters to the trolley car.  “No one questions that the statute, Transportation Code Section 131.012, granted eminent-domain authority to facilitate construction of small electric railways for ferrying Texans short distances between adjacent towns and up and down Main Streets alongside horse-drawn carriages. But it blinks reality to conclude, as the Court does, that the same trolley-car statute confers eminent domain power on private entities aspiring to build—in 2022—a massive $30 billion infrastructure project capable of supporting an elevated, 672-foot-long high-speed train as it traverses hundreds of miles and thousands of privately owned parcels between Houston and Dallas.”

First, Justice Huddle discusses the concept that eminent domain statutes are strictly construed to protect private property rights for those situations whereby cases clearly fall within a statute’s terms. Texas Central, he would hold, does not “clearly fall within” the scope of the interurban electric railway statute.  He would look to the historical context of the statute as applicable to streetcars or trolleys.  “Texas Central’s high-speed rail system is a world apart from this–in design, scale, and intrusiveness.”  He cannot conclude that Texas Central’s project “clearly falls” within the statutory terms.  He also notes that the proposed Texas Central railway would be incompatible with several other statutory provisions within Chapter 131 as it could not navigate municipal streets or alleys as the statute envisions, for example.

Next, the dissent notes that the court should not erode fundamental rights based merely on embracing later-developed technologies.  He cites to Kyllo v. United States, whereby the court held that a police officer’s use of a thermal imager to surveil a home was an unlawful search, which he says stands for the proposition that the “fixed nature of the constitution assures preservation of that degree of privacy against the government that existed when the Fourth Amendment was adopted.” The same is true here, he believes.

Finally, he notes that Texas Central also does not qualify as a “railroad company.”  He would not rely upon the Code Construction Act, as did the court of appeals, which provides that words in the present tense include the future tense.  That Act, he notes, is meant to clarify common situations and this case is “anything but common.”  Texas Central has never operated a railroad and it will take years and billions of dollars before it can ever do so.  This does not “plainly fall within” the terms of the statute and, thus, the statute should be construed in favor of the landowner.

In conclusion, the dissent writes:

“Whether Texas Central’s project will succeed is anyone’s guess. What is certain is that today’s decision places Miles and hundreds of other Texas landowners at Texas Central’s mercy. Texas Central may take their land and, if the project succeeds, bisect each parcel with an enormous infrastructure project on which a train blazes past at 200 miles per hour every thirty minutes. Or it could begin construction and abandon the project, unfinished, leaving behind half-built viaducts leading nowhere. Or it may take their land and do nothing for a decade, triggering a feeble repurchase ‘remedy’ for landowners.”

Conclusion 

Although this case focuses on the narrow issue of statutory interpretation for interurban electric railways, it certainly has the potential to have greater impact on eminent domain cases going forward.  In the coming weeks, I will be releasing a podcast episode with Luke Ellis, a landowner eminent domain attorney from Austin to discuss how this case (and the Texas Supreme Court’s decision in Hlavinka v. HSC Pipeline) will impact Texas landowners going forward.  Be sure to subscribe to the Ag Law in the Field Podcast so you don’t miss it!

 

 

The post Texas Supreme Court: Texas Central Has Eminent Domain Power for High Speed Rail appeared first on Texas Agriculture Law.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/3NloseU
via Abogado Aly Website