Thursday, June 30, 2022

Force Majeure Clauses

Sometimes, despite our best efforts, life and the world throw us curve balls that few could have foreseen and are completely beyond your control. Because of this, sometimes a business contract you entered into may become impossible or impractical to perform. This is where a force majeure clause can come in handy.

Force Majeure Clauses

A force majeure clause in a contract is a provision excusing one or both parties to the contract from performing their contractual obligations when circumstance beyond either parties’ control arise which make performance of the contract either impractical or impossible.

What would constitute such circumstances that would trigger a force majeure clause? Well, these clauses themselves usually list qualifying events. For instance, the force majeure clause may include a qualifying event such as an act of God. An act of God may be further defined as include severe weathers such as flooding, earthquakes, hurricanes, and more. Other qualifying events may include war and acts of terrorisms. Epidemics are also often included in force majeure clauses and there are likely many that utilized a contract’s force majeure clause during the Covid-19 pandemic. Other qualifying events may include things like strikes, labor disputes, and governmental acts such as changes in laws and regulations.

Whether or not you can invoke a contract’s force majeure clause requires a fact specific and fact intensive analysis. The precise language of the clause itself must be examined and there must be evidence that the allegedly triggering event was actually unforeseeable. Furthermore, there must be proof that the event was the reason for a party’s failure to uphold their contractual obligations. States also have different laws regarding the enforceability of force majeure clause so be mindful of those, particularly when you are drafting the contract and including the choice of law to apply in the event of a contract dispute.

While you should definitely consider including a force majeure clause in your contracts, be aware that courts are generally hesitant when approaching them and will do so with caution. These clauses are usually narrowly interpreted by courts and are unlikely to apply outside specifically listed circumstances in the clause itself. The good news is that you may still have options available to excuse lack of contract performance outside of a force majeure clause. In fact, the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) itself has a provision for excuse from contract provision due to impossibility and impracticability. The specific language of the UCC excuses a seller from contract performance when such performance is made impracticable by circumstances not considered when the contract was formed or when such failure to performance is due to an attempt to comply with a governmental regulation or order, regardless of whether the regulation or order later proves to be invalid.

Business Law Attorney

Put strong business contracts in place that protect you and your business in all types of weather. You just never know what life is going to throw your way. At the Kumar Law Firm, we are here to help you plan in the face of an otherwise uncertain future. Contact us today.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/INes2h0
via Abogado Aly Website

Wednesday, June 29, 2022

The Value Standard in a Partnership Agreement

The value standard in a partnership agreement is, as it suggests, the standard at which the partnership is valued. It is a critical component of a partnership agreement and one which should be serious considered before being memorialized in this legally binding contract. At some point, a partner may want to leave the partnership. In this case, the value standard will play a pivotal role in determining the equity the exiting partner has in the partnership. When an improper value standard is used, it discourages partners who want to leave from leaving which can lead to big problems in and of itself. So, before you put just any old standard in your partnership agreement, consider the big implications misvaluing your partnership could have on its longevity.

The Value Standard in a Partnership Agreement

You will often see partnership agreements that set the value standard of the partnership at its book value in order to determine how much a partner has paid for their equity in the business. Book value is the company’s tangible asset value minus the business’s liability times a partner’s equity interest. While you may see the book value as the default method for determining the value of a partner’s equity in a business, it is far from the ideal standard.

When you use the book value, you are only accounting for the value of the company’s tangible assets. Intangible assets, however, can create significant value in a business. Intangible assets include:

  • Patents and other intellectual property,
  • Trade names
  • Customer relationships
  • Goodwill

When it comes down to it, many modern businesses do not have many tangible assets, but can still be successful at generating revenue and steady cash flow. When tangible assets make up only a portion of a business’s value, and even when it may make up a significant chunk of the business’s value, it makes important omissions from the value calculation. As a result, the value of a partner’s equity in the partnership can be greatly reduced.

When including the value standard in your partnership agreement, consider going beyond its book value. Consider the value of goodwill. Consider accounting for how much partners are being paid and the impact that could have on the company’s financial statements. The future cash flow of the business should also be considered in valuing the partner’s equity including the potential impact on the business’s future prospects after the partner leaves. Additionally, market data can be important in valuation of a business. Look to what other similar business operations and cash flow have sold for to get a better idea of what the partnership’s value really is on the open market.

Providing a sound value standard in a partnership agreement is important for a number of reasons. If a partner wants to leave a partnership, having a bad value standard could deter them from leaving. This could lead to resentment and a bad business relation. Such souring relationships can quickly eat away at what would otherwise be a successful business endeavor.

Business Law Attorney

Put a solid partnership agreement in place that promotes the best interests of your business and protects the partners involved. For all of your business agreement needs, you can trust the team at Kumar Law Firm. Contact us today.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/vl5GrVR
via Abogado Aly Website

Oil & Gas Companies Underreported Methane Leaks in the Permian Basin

According to a report by the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology, oil and gas companies in the Permian Basin are underreporting their methane gas emissions to the EPA.

The report found that the companies were not properly tracking, identifying, or controlling the methane leaks and were failing to properly use methane detection and repair technologies.  It also found that a disproportionate share of the methane emissions came from a tiny number of “super-emitting leaks,” which the companies were not tracking or even noticing.

“The point is brutally clear,” the report says.  “The operator’s technology experts were warning that the technology’s biggest risk was not that it would fail, but rather that it would succeed — and in doing so, would find more methane leaks that the operator would then be responsible for, with all of the accompanying repair costs and reputational risks that might ensue.”

Methane is the second-largest contributor to global warming, accounting for 30% of global warming.  It is 85 times as potent as carbon dioxide.  When captured and stored properly, it is the main component of natural gas and a revenue generator.  However, when methane leaks into the atmosphere, it becomes one of our earth’s most dangerous climate pollutants.

The Committee discovered the companies were underreporting their methane emissions during its investigations of ten oil and gas companies in the Permian Basin:

  • Admiral Permian Resources
  • Ameredev II
  • Chevron
  • ConocoPhillips
  • Coterra Energy
  • Devon Energy
  • ExxonMobil
  • Mewbourne Oil
  • Occidental Petroleum
  • Pioneer Natural Resources

The Committee chose to focus on the Permian Basin (a land area from West Texas to Southeast New Mexico) because it is the largest methane-emitting region in the U.S.  It accounted for 42.6% of U.S. oil production in December 2021.

The report found that Permian Basin oil and gas companies are failing to address super-emitting leaks, failing to use quantification data to mitigate methane leak emissions, and deploying innovative Methane Leak Detection and Repair (LDAR) technologies in a limited and inconsistent manner.

The largest amount of methane is emitted when the equipment malfunctions, known as “methane leaks.”  A small subset of massive methane leaks, known as “super-emitting leaks,” are responsible for a disproportionate amount of the oil and gas sector’s total methane emissions.  Just 12% of methane emitters are responsible for 50% of methane emissions in the Permian Basin.  One company experienced a single leak equivalent to more than 80% of all the methane emissions it reported to the EPA.

Super-emitting leaks are difficult to track because they tend to be intermittent and unpredictable, starting and stopping irregularly for extended periods of time.  Thus, companies must be prepared to track and identify super-emitting leaks outside of normal procedures.  However, the report found that Permian Basin companies are unprepared for identifying and tracking the super-emitting leaks.  Most companies don’t even have a definition of a super-emitting leak: “Of the ten operators that provided information to the Committee, nine out of ten revealed that they lack any internal definition of a super-emitting leak, whether persistent or intermittent.  Only one operator cited an actual size threshold for a super-emitting leak.”  One company even stated that it preferred not to single-out super leaks because it is distracting from its objective of identifying emission leaks generally.

The Committee report urged the companies to make greater and more accurate use of the innovative leak surveillance equipment known as Methane Leak Detection and Repair, or LDAR.

Innovative LDAR technology allows operators to properly measure and track their methane emissions and is adept at finding leaks, including super-emitters.

“Many innovative technologies can provide operators with data regarding the size of individual methane emission events within their operations.  But the operators themselves must accept the validity of these measurements, integrate the measurement data into their repair procedures, and respond to super-emitting leaks as quickly as possible,” the report stated.

The companies were not utilizing this technology, according to the report.

“Oil and gas companies are deploying innovative LDAR technologies in a limited and inconsistent manner,” the report said.  “Most deployments remain in the pilot phase with scopes that are too narrow to support emissions reductions on a timeline that meets the urgency of the climate crisis.”

As a result, the companies’ methane emissions “are likely significantly higher than official data.”

Currently, the EPA requires oil and gas firms to inspect for leaks twice a year.  However, U.S. has recently made methane a major priority.  The EPA issued a proposed rule to strengthen the regulatory framework around methane emissions in the oil and gas sector for the first time.  Biden’s new proposals at the U.N. climate summit represented the first time U.S. will address methane seepage from the oil and gas industry.  Oil companies will need to keep up with LDAR technology and policies to detect super-leaks and properly report emissions, so our future generations can live and breathe.

If you or someone you know was injured in a methane leak-related accident, contact our experienced oilfield accident lawyer at Morrow & Sheppard LLP for a free, confidential consultation.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/C2nXS8E
via Abogado Aly Website

Were the Mineral Deeds a Gift or a Sale? It Made a Difference.

Co-author Carolina Cuppitelli*

The question presented in Aaron v. Fisher et al: Did mineral deeds bestow separate property upon the grantees by gift, or did they convey a community property interest to the grantees and their spouses by sale for consideration?

Why was the question important? A gift is the grantee’s separate property; a sale is community property if the grantee is married.

In 1971, Lilly Parker conveyed to each of her six children, including W. T. and Chester, an undivided 1/12 interest in minerals in land in Glasscock County, Texas. Each deed recited consideration and referred to the conveyance as “this sale.”

There followed a series of intestate successions, details of which are more tedious than the entire first chapter of the Gospel of Matthew and not significant for our discussion. Among Lilly’s descendants were Aaron, the appellant, and the Elams and the Fishers, the appellees. Pioneer, relying on an affidavit of death and heirship from Aaron and a division order signed by him, paid Aaron royalties that Pioneer credited to the mineral interest originally conveyed from Lilly.

The conveyances were sales for consideration

The Court held that the 1971 deeds conveyed the mineral interests by sale for consideration and not by gift. The deeds expressly referred to the conveyance as a “sale” and recited a purported consideration of $10.00. The Court declared that the plain language of the unambiguous deeds indicated that the parties intended for the conveyances to be sales for consideration. It follows, then, that the mineral interests became the community property of W.T. and Chester and ultimately passed to their spouses. Had the transaction been a gift, the minerals would have passed to their sister, Aaron’s aunt. Did Lilly intend a sale? We suspect not in this mother-to-children transaction, but the plain language of the document required the Court to call it a sale.

Money Had and Received

The trial court granted the Fishers’ claim for money had and received. That remedy is a form of equitable relief to prevent unjust enrichment when the defendant holds money that rightly belongs to the plaintiff. The Fishers prevailed because they established that the royalty payments Aaron received from Pioneer, in equity and good conscience, belonged to them.

Takeaways

First, in any document transferring property is the importance of accurately stating the parties’ intent. Perhaps Lilly intended to give, not sell, the mineral interests to her children, but because of the express language of the deed the court was left with little choice but to declare the conveyance a sale. Had the scrivener clearly stated that Lilly wanted to gift her interests to her children, the result would have been different.

Second, make a will, even though you are currently immortal and therefore don’t need one, and you might have to pay a lawyer. Fail to accomplish this modest task and upon your transition to the hereafter your loved ones will curse you for your indolence and lack of foresight and your memory will be diminished from the dearly departed to the just plain departed. A mournful legacy indeed, but you’ll be dead so maybe you don’t care.

Your musical interlude.

*Carolina is a Gray Reed summer associate and will soon begin her third year at SMU law school.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/7xO2UJ1
via Abogado Aly Website

Tuesday, June 28, 2022

Longhorn Litigation Lives

As Dickens famously wrote in Bleak House: “Jarndyce and Jarndyce drones on. This scarecrow of a suit has, in course of time, become so complicated that no man alive knows what it means. … Innumerable children have been born into the cause; innumerable young people have married into it; innumerable old people have died out of it.”

So to, the affirmative-action litigation about admissions policy at the University of Texas at Austin, where the Fifth Circuit held, inter alia, that an organization called “Students for Fair Admissions” was not barred by claim preclusion from bringing suit when (1) its principals were involved in earlier litigation, but did not control the new entity and had sued before in different capacities, and (2) the facts about UT’s policies and the makeup of its student body had materially changed since the earlier litigation. Students for Fair Admission, Inc. v. Univ. of Tex. at Austin, No. 21-50715 (June 20, 2022).

The post Longhorn Litigation Lives appeared first on 600 Camp.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/RPsxzQe
via Abogado Aly Website

Thursday, June 23, 2022

Not too late for an injunction

Robinson v. Ardoin addressed whether to stay a preliminary injunction in a highly technical Voting Rights Act case about Louisiana’s congressional districts. The Court’s analysis of timeliness is of general interest in preliminary injunction practice involving similar situations (a board election or vote, etc.), even though some of the policy interests involved are unique to elections for public office. The key facts were:

  • The primary election at issue was five months away; the deadline for a candidate to qualify for that election by paying a fee was approximately a month away, which was the path chosen by most candidates;
  • While “multiple mailings could confuse some voters,” there was “[m]ore than enough time … for the state to assuage any uncertainty,” especially when no one had yet cast a ballot; and
  • While “administrative burdens” related to equipment maintenance and voter-roll review were legitimate concerns, evidence showed that the state had significant administrative experience in adjusting to changes in the time, place, and manner of elections.

No. 22-30333 (June 12, 2022).

The post Not too late for an injunction appeared first on 600 Camp.



from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/dxHRe3q
via Abogado Aly Website

Supreme Court Grants Cert in Bittner v U.S. On FBAR Nonwillful Penalty Per Form or Per Account Issue (6/21/22)

The Supreme Court today granted certiorari in the Bittner case to address the issue of whether the FBAR nonwillful penalty is per form or per account.  See Order List, p. 2, here.  I covered the key points at this stage in a prior blog.  Solicitor General Acquiesces in Bittner Petition for Cert on Issue of FBAR Nonwillful Penalty Per Form or Per Account (Federal Tax Crimes Blog 5/19/22), here.  So I will defer further comment now.

The docket entries where the briefings and other documents as they are filed may be retrieved in the following web pages:

  • Supreme Court here.
  • Scotusblog here (Note, as of this posting the cert granted entry has not been posted but should be posted by the end of the day.


from Texas Bar Today https://ift.tt/KnvGq5t
via Abogado Aly Website